Clicking on banner ads enables JWR to constantly improve
Jewish World Review May 16, 2003 / 14 Iyar 5763

Steve Young

Steve Young
JWR's Pundits
World Editorial
Cartoon Showcase

Mallard Fillmore

Michael Barone
Mona Charen
Linda Chavez
Ann Coulter
Greg Crosby
Larry Elder
Don Feder
Suzanne Fields
James Glassman
Paul Greenberg
Bob Greene
Betsy Hart
Nat Hentoff
David Horowitz
Marianne Jennings
Michael Kelly
Mort Kondracke
Ch. Krauthammer
Lawrence Kudlow
Dr. Laura
John Leo
Michelle Malkin
Jackie Mason
Chris Matthews
Michael Medved
Kathleen Parker
Wes Pruden
Sam Schulman
Amity Shlaes
Roger Simon
Tony Snow
Thomas Sowell
Cal Thomas
Jonathan S. Tobin
Ben Wattenberg
George Will
Bruce Williams
Walter Williams
Mort Zuckerman

Consumer Reports

Liar, liar, American Idol's on fire? | It's spreading faster than SARS. Faster than Kelly Clarkson's meteoric rise to People covergal.

First it was Bennett.

Next the New York Times.

Now..the worst: American Idol.

Holy Art Buchwald. The show, nay the Goliath conglomerate, number one TV show, number one record, number one meanie; all of them are (alleged to be) the result of a stolen idea. Stolen from the little guy. A little guy who had an American Dream AND an American copyright..and that was AMERICAN IDOL!

Harry Keane Jr. of Irving, Texas, says he conceived the Fox show in 1994 and says he can prove it. Of course, a court of law and itís judge will be...the judge of that, but he seems to have some interesting substantiation, including witnesses to support his claim that he was out pitching the same concepts as Freemantle Media (Simon Fuller, Simon Cowell) of the UK, first presented as "Pop Idol" in England, then "American Idol" in the US."

Mr. Keane's release says "The proposal detailed the entire production from concept to broadcast, including the 'initial' national auditions of 18- 27 year old talent, to the final 13 week television series, where celebrity judges and the viewing audience would vote on the final 20 contestants each week. Viewers would be able to vote by calling an 800 number or go on-line and vote over the Internet."

In fact, Keane says his proposal is identical in every detail to the proposal made by Fuller and Cowell when they pitched "Pop Idol" to Thames Television in London.

Now I certainly don't want cast aspersions on a television ratings colossus. They certainly have enough grief just trying to figure out how to spend the show's profits. You get the feeling that if this UK and Australian (Fox's Rupert Murdoch) cartel truly wanted to thank the American people for its success they could easily wipe out the national deficit and still have enough change for...well, for paying the attorneys battling Mr. Keane's lawsuit. But nonetheless, if Mr. Keane has anything, there's going to be quite a bit of a problem for the Simons, et al.

We can at least take solace that Kimberly doesn't have to be drug through the dirt too. It was difficult enough to see her go deal with Simon's "critiques." Let Reuben and Clay be cross-examined in the courts. They have the shoulders to handle it. At least Reuben does.

Wow. What does this say about Reality TV programming? It's like these television producers don't have to write their own shows. Reality shows without writing? Tell me it hasn't come to this. Worse than the lack of writing. Does this mean that reality television is just plagiarism massaged into 26 weeks of programming?

Stolen ideas in Hollywood? Tell me it's just a bad dream.

Of course, this could all be just someone looking for a quick payday, but if this is legitimate and we find there is actually thievery and a dearth of original ideas in television then I blame only one person...the writer. Why aren't they coming up with good, fresh ideas instead of forcing these producers to steal to make do? It's a crying shame. Hopefully it stops here. I don't know what I would do if movie producers are driven to lift ideas from other films, or worse, old TV shows. Damn you writers. Damn you to hell.

JWR contributor Steve Young, Prism Award winner and Humanitas Prize nominee for his television writing, is contributing editor at the Writers Guild of America's "Written By" magazine. He is the author of "Great Failures of the Extremely Successful: Mistakes, Adversity, Failure and Other Stepping Stones to Success," "The 130 Tales of Winchell Mink," Harper Collins (Winter, 2003) and the director/writer of "My Dinner With Ovitz." His website is Comment by clicking here.

04/16/03: TAKE ME OUT OF THE BALL GAME: Politics pitched at national pastime and baseball strikes out
04/11/03: Goodbye Shecky Al-Sahaf, We Hardly Knew Ye
04/04/03: An open letter to the right...and left
03/25/03: Should we be funny during war?
03/19/03: The 2003 Academy aWARds
03/04/03: Energy shortage vs energy profit: A Political Primer
02/28/03: Celebrities for war
02/20/03: So you want to be a liberal talk show host
02/18/03: The Sting, Part II: Osama turns himself in
02/10/03: Michael Jackson threat level raised to "orange"
01/23/03: Can we really blame HBO for terrorism?
01/09/03: You can buy your very own family...on eBay
01/02/03: A look back at a sorry but pretty funny year
12/30/02: Using 2002ís failures to make a successful 2003
12/20/02: McCartney Credit Reverse Sets A Dangerous Precedent
12/18/02: Radio talk takes a surprise hit
12/16/02: Apologies running rampant: The country is in a sorry state
12/13/02: Lott apologizes for his apologies
11/26/02: Finding the McTunity within their McFailure
11/15/02: Can the Dems learn from Lincoln's failures?
11/06/02: The Day After... who'll comfort me now?
11/04/02: We can all fight ageism!
10/29/02: Was I totally responsible for the market's upsurge?
10/09/02: Finding The Bull Within: Wall Street Needs To Rethink The "F" Word
10/01/02: Merriam-Webster Needs To Rethink the "F" word
09/25/02: Held up in the passing lane ... and life's other positive curve balls
09/23/02: Shrinking the waist problem: Using Good Old American Failure To Lose Inches
09/17/02: Earth to Florida: No more elections
09/11/02: The humor will return. Just not yet
09/09/02: Bush coalition on fast track
08/30/02: N'Sync's Bass gets NASA okay: Former astronauts Gagarin and Glenn form boy band
08/21/02: Insider's a good thing
08/05/02: America goes Madison Ave.: The Selling of America
07/29/02: ROCKIN' RENO: The Newest Political Strategy For Filling The Coffers
07/23/02: Is Wall Street the enemy? No, but that's where the enemy hides
07/10/02: Cooking the books
06/27/02: Apocalypse now!?
06/14/02: Coulter for the defense?
05/21/02: SUICIDE BOMBER KILLS SELF! NO ONE ELSE INJURED! Inept bomber is refused entrance into Paradise. 72 Virgins breathe sigh of relief
05/19/02: Hey world! How about trying the shoe on the other foot hypotheses
05/13/02: AM Radio and Enron
05/03/02: "Deep Throat" to Be Revealed ... But will America Swallow It!?
04/29/02: Britney Spears next in line to blast off into orbit
04/22/02: Former Liberal Seeks Conservative Book Deal
04/15/02: If you truly care about America, you'll read this column
04/01/02: My Uncle Miltie
03/27/02: The Fightin' Righties
03/20/02: Woody Allen refuses to cast self...
03/18/02: The Realies
02/19/02: Greenspan Announces Lower (Television Network) Interest Rates
02/15/02: Ken Lay sells soul to the devil: Beelzebub loses life's savings
02/12/02: Enron's Skilling mistakenly takes the Fourth, forcing him to spill his guts
02/06/02: BOOSTING THE SAGGING ECONOMY: Let Green Stamps be our financial brassiere
01/24/02: "I'M THE ONE!"
01/16/02: Goodbye "Rincoln Continental," we hardry knew ye
01/14/02: "But He Was Such A Good Boy" gene, found to be defective
01/04/02: PLAY BUZKASHI!
12/31/01: Come on war. You can do better!
12/26/01: NOT MY OSAMA!
12/24/01: TIME caves
12/20/01: Finally! Friends of Color
12/14/01: Bin Laden's Funniest Home Videos
12/10/01: What if Catching bin Laden is in dispute?
11/30/01: Back to normal...too bad
11/16/01: Osama not enough for some
11/09/01: Networks at war!
11/05/01: Bridges Over Troubled Water
10/29/01: The other terrorists
10/16/01: Diary Of A Young Defense Department Comedy Writer
10/01/01: Playlands, burgers, and family sanity
09/25/01: Dissent is walking on red, white and blue egg shells
09/21/01: OPEN LETTER THE MOST HIGH (RE: Falwell and Robertson comments)
09/17/01: Gary, we miss ya
09/10/01: Smelling out a real hero
09/04/01: Don't give up on that dream!
08/24/01: Pitch day at the Mouse
08/21/01: It Depends On What Your Definition Of "Unlimited" Is


© 2002, Steve Young