|
Jewish World Review Nov. 13, 2001/ 27 Mar-Cheshvan, 5762
Marianne M. Jennings
http://www.NewsAndOpinion.com --
HOWARD FINEMAN of Newsweek and liberal mind, confesses that employing torture against the al-Qaeda/ bin Laden crowd is not a bad idea. Alan Dershowitz, defender of the guilty, agrees, if probable cause and a judge are involved pre-torture.
When he isn't calling for torture with a warrant, Mr. Dershowitz demands national ID cards. He who damned sexual McCarthyism during l'affair Monica now favors human tracking.
Democrats are offering up unanimous consent for expanded FBI wiretapping. The Justice Department now listens to lawyers' conversations with clients in custody.
Those in the business of rights, privacy, and generic excuse-making for criminals have jumped ship. You can never find a liberal when you need one. When the going gets tough, the liberals run for cover.
During World War II, Bob Hope took himself and a bevy of beauties to the front lines. Betty Grable and her gambs visited the troops. Today, Hollywood liberals hire extra security and hide out on Malibu's cliffs. Jennifer Aniston flaked out on a charity event, fearful that radical Muslims' might succeed in their strategic goal of Hollywood brain trust annihilation.
Liberals were out in full force for Andrea Yates. NBC's Katie Couric did a little fundraising for Yates' defense fund on the Today Show for post-partum sufferers everywhere. But women drowning children are no threat to Berkeley or Ann Arbor. Terrorism hits home. Air travel, the media and Democrats' mail are targets. Nary a frightened liberal eyebrow rises to protest as their nemesis, John Ashcroft, asks for all but the funding for rubber hoses and hotter interrogation lights.
Liberal icon Thurgood Marshall wrote, "grave threats to liberty often come in times of urgency, when constitutional rights seem too extravagant to endure." I urge my liberal friends to remember their principles and endure.
However, the difference between what have been their relatively benign but intellectually fashionable principles and the principles of conviction is that the latter apply even when it hurts. A conservative's fear is the loss of freedom, not the loss of life. Liberals have a non-believing sinner's fear of death. This Shermanesque march over the Bill of Rights is fueled by cowardice. Conservatives are of little help, having joined their comrades in totalitarianism without a peep as they flee from anthrax.
When terrorist networks are curbed, an inevitability despite media hand wringing, we will regret this infringement of rights. Conservatives only asked the Warren court for the right to use confessions spewed by the guilty before they realize Dershowitz is available. We never asked for jailhouse eavesdropping and ubiquitous wiretaps.
ID cards are an awful idea. Ronald Reagan's response to this ID idea during one of its many iterations was, "Maybe we should just brand all the babies."
An FBI with unchecked powers is an idea whose time should never come. Society would be a better place if we eavesdropped on all lawyers' conversations. Society would be perfect if we tortured lawyers. But both trample rights. Eavesdropping on jailhouse conversations is wrong, even between a lawyer and a client of Arab lineage who has taken crop dusting lessons and has a penchant for powdered donuts.
What is most irksome about these constitutional tramplings is that liberal convictions remain selectively active. The Fourth Amendment is fair game because the liberal mind won't touch immigration. Halting all Arab pedigree entries would put a big dent in terrorism here. Place a curb on all immigration and we might lick the welfare state issue too. Rather than face such an offense to diversity, liberals gut the constitution. Even Mr. Bush is too gracious in this regard.
The prickly part of principles is standing firm when your hide is tanned. Taking away rights to solve unspeakable crimes and prevent more sounds mighty tempting. However, the price of living in a free society is that, on occasion, both domestic and foreign nuts wreak havoc. No amount of homeland security can curb the deviants. There can never be guarantees. But, the liberal mind, accustomed to punitive damages for life's accidents and a Consumer Product Safety Commission that recalls Barbies with defective tube tops, cannot accept risk.
Instead, they turn a free nation of stalwarts into sheep that accept daily advances by a wolf that will destroy the magnificent constitutional barriers that cost as many of our citizens their lives in the American Revolution as in the September 11 attacks. Too much is taken too quickly with too little dissent.
The inevitable next attack is a frightening prospect, but its possibility is not as worrisome as the damage to the Constitution. The FBI tapping into the Internet with Carnivore is the end of privacy. Torture is the stuff of rogue nations. We are a better people and nation than this. Please, could just a few liberals, who more than self their country love, and a few conservatives, who know that our liberty is in law, join me in these
11/01/01: Unlucky in sports
|