Clicking on banner ads enables JWR to constantly improve
Jewish World Review July 9, 2002 / 29 Tamuz, 5762

James K. Glassman

Jim Glassman
JWR's Pundits
World Editorial
Cartoon Showcase

Mallard Fillmore

Michael Barone
Mona Charen
Linda Chavez
Ann Coulter
Greg Crosby
Larry Elder
Don Feder
Suzanne Fields
Paul Greenberg
Bob Greene
Betsy Hart
Nat Hentoff
David Horowitz
Marianne Jennings
Michael Kelly
Mort Kondracke
Ch. Krauthammer
Lawrence Kudlow
Dr. Laura
John Leo
David Limbaugh
Michelle Malkin
Chris Matthews
Michael Medved
Kathleen Parker
Wes Pruden
Sam Schulman
Amity Shlaes
Tony Snow
Thomas Sowell
Cal Thomas
Jonathan S. Tobin
Ben Wattenberg
George Will
Bruce Williams
Walter Williams
Mort Zuckerman

Consumer Reports

Competition cure-all |
Not long ago, I'll admit that I was one of the people worried about a broadband "crisis" - not enough Americans with high-speed connections to the Internet. But over the past year and a half, broadband has boomed. I would like to see it boom even more, and I have ideas on how to make that happen.

But let's not panic. First, look at the facts.

Today, four out of five U.S. families have access to broadband, and about 15 percent of families currently subscribe - at an average cost of $50 a month, a significant outlay. Still, Americans are adopting broadband faster than they adopted color TV or compact discs. In the latest quarter, BellSouth boosted subscribership 140 percent compared to a year earlier. In Connecticut, where I live, the greater Hartford area now has 366,000 broadband subscribers - an increase of 198 percent in 12 months.

While bureaucrats, legislators and judges at the federal level have been trying to find a quick fix through new laws and regulations, the states and the telecom companies themselves have quietly and effectively been applying their own market-based remedies. Washington already has done the important work - establishing the blueprint for deregulation of local service in the Telecommunications Act of 1996. The key to expanding broadband is opening up the local loop - the last mile. The four mega-Bell companies still control 95 percent of residential lines, but in states like New York, things are changing, thanks to the kind of reasonable pricing that the Telecom Act requires.

Still, some folks can't leave well enough alone. Sen. Joseph Lieberman, D-Conn., recently issued a 61-page report calling for a grandiose national broadband policy - read: "industrial policy" - comparing his program to President Kennedy's challenge to "land a man on the moon" before 1970.

But broadband has more in common with television than it does with moon shots. For any new technology to succeed, it needs to be: 1) available, 2) inexpensive, and 3) compelling in its content.

Broadband has met the first test. It's still too expensive, and the only remedy is intense competition. Bills like Tauzin-Dingell, passed by the House earlier this year, or equivalent ideas now kicking around the FCC, would have the opposite effect. The four Bells would be left alone as telecom monopolists, and monopolists, as any economist will tell you, limit supply and raise prices. The inevitable outcome would be re-regulation of the telecom monopoly, and we'd be back where we started before the break up of the original AT&T.

As for content: Here's where the feds can play a constructive role, and the Bush administration, to its great credit, is doing so. Through tax incentives (a moratorium on Internet taxes and accelerated depreciation), changes in intellectual-property law and a more aggressive presence of government as a purchaser of broadband services (a la the Kennedy moon shot), Washington can help private firms improve content on the Web. Right now, for most Americans, there's no killer application, no compelling reason to pay $600 a year for faster connections. Content will improve, however, and more people will sign up for broadband. But who is to say what the "right" level of broadband use at this stage should be? Only the market.

On June 13, President Bush said, "This country must be aggressive about the expansion of broadband." I agree. The United States should aggressively remove barriers to broadband progress - and that means ending the Bells' grip on the last mile. The Telecom Act of 1996 sets out guidelines for doing just that, and it is happening, slowly but surely, and mainly because of smart action at the state level.

But being aggressive does not mean destroying the competition and giving the Bells a clear field. It means encouraging competition by enforcing the Telecom Act. If the FCC wants to play a constructive role, it should tell the states flat out: "Adopt the kind of reasonable pricing for unbundled elements of the local loop that will foster a slam-bang battle among firms." That's what happened in long distance, and it needs to happen as well in local service and in broadband.

Trust the monopolists? No thanks. Instead, trust competition.

Enjoy this writer's work? Why not sign-up for the daily JWR update. It's free. Just click here.

JWR contributor James K. Glassman is the host of Tech Central Station. Comment by clicking here.


06/26/02: Rebalancing Act
06/21/02: Technology Back on Track
06/19/02: Star Power?
06/12/02: The Beautiful Line
06/10/02: Squashing broadband
06/06/02: Frank investing advice
06/04/02: Say it ain't so, George
05/29/02: He moves in mysterious ways
05/22/02: Reel in these stocks
05/15/02: It's a "small" world
05/08/02: Goldi-stocks
05/02/02: Japanese stock growth?
04/30/02: Trust the Bells?
04/24/02: Being there is best revenge
04/18/02: I'm a Seoul man
04/16/02: Analyze this
04/09/02: The Dot.Con con game
03/21/02: The companies you keep
02/28/02: Trusting monopolists
02/22/02: How not to get taken when buying stocks
02/06/02: Investing After 9/11
01/30/02: Blue Light Specials? Advice on snapping-up K-Mart or Enron stock
01/24/02: Dare to be obscure
01/16/02: Bank on this
01/10/02: What goes down...
01/04/02: An asset-focused investor finds 'deep value' stocks
12/26/01: High-Tech Funds Low On Tech
12/19/01: Tech Sector: Blodget, Meeker, and You
12/12/01: Enron's lessons: Be skeptical of experts
12/04/01: CLECs alive and well, but not if Tauzin-Dingell passes
11/15/01: The "Next Big Thing" in Technology?
10/30/01: A National I.D. Card? Yes; Run By Larry Ellison? No
10/25/01: Without Bayer, we're bare to bioterror
10/18/01: The Battle of Biotech
10/05/01: Two Techs for Tough Times
09/26/01: The Information War
09/05/01: Tech firms built to last through tough times
08/23/01: Stocks on the A-List
08/17/01: Labor and management finding online learning to their liking
08/08/01: Game makers poised to profit
07/19/01: Trade Promotion Authority: High-Techís Key Component for Competitiveness
07/12/01: Nothingís arbitrary about the contrarians
06/27/01: Look to Politics to Find Broadband's Market Cap Shortfall
06/22/01: Tech Commodity Buys Available for Mining
06/18/01: The Blackout Portfolio
06/14/01: The conservation myth stars as latest (sub)urban legend
06/07/01: Will America go high tech on the high seas?
06/05/01: 'Price gouging' doesn't cut it as reason for rising energy prices
06/01/01: Authentication tools opening up opportunities in online security
05/25/01: 'Price gouging' doesnít cut it as reason for rising energy prices
05/21/01: Banking on High-Tech Education
05/17/01: It's No Time to Go Wobbly on Kyoto
05/02/01: Diversify with techís leaders
04/26/01: To Revive The New Economy, Release A Chokehold   —   Break Up The Bells
04/24/01: Whoís To Blame For Broadband Crisis? Wired Article Points To Bells
04/19/01: The Bush Budget
04/12/01: To revive The New Economy, release a chokehold --- break up the Bells
04/04/01: Even as stocks have fallen, the Net keeps booming
03/28/01: Whereís The Profit In Biotech Future?
03/22/01: The Joy of Debt: The last thing we should want is a U.S. Treasury flush with cash
03/19/01: 'Defensive' Stocks in the NASDAQ
03/15/01: Bush administration must say no to Jane and Kyoto
03/08/01: Time to buy small caps? Consider these five great techs
03/01/01: Billís and Larryís continued political adventures
02/26/01: Chips on the Dips?
02/23/01: How Tauzin Can Keep His Word And Stop Telecom "Remonopolization"
02/13/01: Consumers, WAKE UP! Middlemen are ripping you off
02/02/01: Publicity-Seeking Politicians and Contingency-Fee Lawyers Corrupt the Law
01/26/01: DoubleClick, eBay And Their Promising Ilk
01/24/01: Will Cyberspace Look Like France or America?
12/27/00: Cut interest, taxes and regulation to save high-tech economy
12/20/00: Close, But No Big Czar
12/15/00: A Down Year? Maybe. But Letís Put It in Perspective
12/13/00: Clintonís sorry midnight race into history
12/07/00: Is Telecomís Future The Bells, The Bells, and Only The Bells?
12/01/00: Money talks and walks in election aftermath
11/29/00: Climate Treaty Deadlock Shows Lack of Consensus and Common Sense
11/23/00: Climate change participants donít listen to reasons for uncertainty
11/21/00: Will Regulators Create a Recession?
11/14/00: The Election and the Market
10/26/00: Hang on for the long term
10/25/00: On privacy, one size doesnít fit all
10/24/00: Perish the bearish thought
10/19/00: Beating hunger --- the biggest prize
10/13/00: Way to play biotech
10/12/00: Bush vs. Gore on Technology
10/11/00: Global Climate Scare: Fools Rush In
10/05/00: Avoid the Apple Trap
10/03/00: Goodbye, anti-Microsoft crusader --- and good riddance
09/29/00: Should You Invest in Tech IPOs?
09/27/00: Could technology end airline delays?
09/22/00: Donít Forget Small Caps
09/20/00: Is the New York Times Rooting for Disaster?
09/13/00: The Best Argument Against Net Regulation
08/30/00: Political Risk in Big Drug Stocks
07/27/00: Tech Dividends
07/25/00: Government Privacy Violators
07/20/00: If I Had to Pick One Tech Stock
07/18/00: Our Favorite Lawsuit
07/13/00: Silicon Valley East
07/11/00: Election 2000: Year of the Investor Class?
07/07/00: Adventures on the
07/06/00:The Difference Between Bill Gates and Larry Ellison
06/29/00: In the Chips
06/27/00: Free market wins in Federal Court!
06/22/00: Wireless Bargains?
06/20/00: Is Your SUV Warming the Planet?
06/15/00: Shopping for Government
06/13/00: Top 10 Tech Stocks
06/08/00: Riding the eBook Wave
06/06/00: "The Last Mile"
06/02/00: Keep Buying!
05/31/00: Who Asked the FTC to Regulate Online Privacy?
05/25/00: "When Itís Time to Sell"
05/23/00: End the "Telephone Tax"
05/16/00: Time Warner Gets a Bad Rap

© 2002, Tech Central Station