Jewish World Review August 16, 2002 / 8 Elul, 5762

Jack Kemp

Jack Kemp
JWR's Pundits
World Editorial
Cartoon Showcase

Mallard Fillmore

Michael Barone
Mona Charen
Linda Chavez
Ann Coulter
Greg Crosby
Larry Elder
Don Feder
Suzanne Fields
Paul Greenberg
Bob Greene
Betsy Hart
Nat Hentoff
David Horowitz
Marianne Jennings
Michael Kelly
Mort Kondracke
Ch. Krauthammer
Lawrence Kudlow
Dr. Laura
John Leo
David Limbaugh
Michelle Malkin
Chris Matthews
Michael Medved
Kathleen Parker
Wes Pruden
Sam Schulman
Amity Shlaes
Tony Snow
Thomas Sowell
Cal Thomas
Jonathan S. Tobin
Ben Wattenberg
George Will
Bruce Williams
Walter Williams
Mort Zuckerman

Consumer Reports

The territorial truth | As we are learning in Afghanistan, ending the war is just the beginning of securing the peace. The same will be true of the Arab/Israeli conflict, which is why I have written extensively about the need for a Marshall Plan for Palestine and the Middle East. It will be necessary for the West to remain engaged in the Middle East in order to ensure democracy and freedom for all the Christians, Jews and Muslims living in the region.

George Orwell said that the first duty of intelligent men is to restate the obvious, and that is precisely what Secretary of Defense Donald Rumsfeld did last week with respect to the territorial dispute between Jews and Arabs, Israelis and Palestinians.

Speaking at a briefing last Wednesday, he gave a quick history lesson on the Middle-East that in one sentence summarized the essence of the problem: "If you have a country that's a sliver and you can see three sides of it from a high hotel building, you've got to be careful what you give away and to whom you give it."

When Israeli diplomats refer to Israel's "security," they are not just talking about defending its people -- Jewish and Arab -- from terrorist attacks; they are talking about enabling Israel to defend itself from those who seek to destroy it. It is not the case that Israel refuses to grant the Palestinians self-rule, and we should never forget that under Menachem Begin's Likud government Israel gave the Siani back to Egypt.

There have been two formal attempts by the international community since Jordan achieved independence to create Palestinian self-rule in the territories that roughly encompass Gaza and the West Bank, once in 1947 and again in 2000, which the Arab world rejected in 1947 and then Yasser Arafat rejected in 2000. After the Arabs rejected the 1947 effort under the U.N. partition plan and Israel was created the following year, Azzam Pasha, secretary-general of the Arab League, declared, "This will be a war of extermination." True to his word, the armies of Egypt, Jordan, Lebanon, Syria and Iraq attacked Israel. During this war, Jordan illegally occupied the West Bank territories and Egypt illegally occupied Gaza.

Efforts to destroy Israel continued unabated during the next 19 years, and in 1967 war broke out again. This time, it was Egypt's President Gamel Nasser who said, "Our basic objective will be the destruction of Israel." During the ensuing Six Day War, Jordan lost the West Bank and Egypt lost Gaza to Israel.

This is the history to which Rumsfeld had reference when he said: "My feeling about the so-called occupied territories is that there was a war, Israel urged neighboring countries not to get involved in it once it started, they all jumped in, and they lost a lot of real estate to Israel because Israel prevailed in that conflict. In the intervening period, they've made some settlements in various parts of the so-called occupied area, which was the result of a war, which they won."

Between 1948 and 1967, when the West Bank and Gaza were under Arab control, no attempt was ever made to create a separate Palestinian state there. Instead, Jordan annexed the West Bank and gave its residents full Jordanian citizenship. The question over who should control what parts of the so-called occupied territories remains a legitimate dispute today. Those lands, including the cities of Hebron, Schechem and Bethlehem, have ancient biblical roots. Jews always lived there until they were pushed out in the 1920s. The land also included the Western Wall of Jerusalem, and people tend to forget that until the 1967 war, Jews could not pray at that, their most holy of sites. Hence it is not correct to describe Israeli communities that grew up on this disputed territory as "settlements" on "occupied territory."

The problem with those who claim that the conflict would be over if the Israelis simply ended the occupation is that they assume Palestinians are the legal, sovereign owners of these territories and what their borders should be. As Rumsfeld pointed out, those are precisely the questions that still need to be resolved.

Rumsfeld deserves commendation for his truth-telling and his clarity. As we all work and pray for a peaceful solution to the crises in the Middle East, we will do well to keep his reservations in mind. History can repeat itself, so who could fault a sliver of a democracy for insisting that there be a functioning Palestinian democracy before it gives back precious land it won in a defensive war?

Ultimately, there will have to be compromise on both sides, and the United States will have to support economic aid and free trade for the region. We already have a free-trade agreement with Jordan, which could be extended to other Arab nations willing to make peace with Israel and guarantee Israel's security from terrorist assault.

Enjoy this writer's work? Why not sign-up for the daily JWR update. It's free. Just click here.

Jack Kemp is co-director of Empower America and chairman of Foundation for the Defense of Democracies. Comment by clicking here.


08/01/02: No economic security without economic growth
07/24/02: 'Infectious greed' and other miasmatic diseases
07/12/02: Solving the "Arab Problem"
07/02/02: July 4, 2002
06/26/02: Unsigning an unratified treaty
06/10/02: Establishing 'givens' in Middle East geo-politics
06/10/02: New role models for Africa
05/02/02: What wasn't heard out of Crawford
04/25/02: In search of Arab dignity
04/16/02: Taxes and history lessons
04/09/02: Arabs must take a stand against terrorism
04/02/02: Nuevo dependencia and world government
03/26/02: Bureaucratic buffoonery at the INS
03/19/02: California's newest citizen politician
03/06/02: Peaceful relations or public relations?
02/27/02: American trade policy at war with itself
02/20/02: Three-conjecture strategy on global warming
02/14/02: Nurturing democratic capitalism in Afghanistan
02/06/02: Gephardt embraces tax cuts and tax simplification
01/30/02: Just the facts
01/22/02: 'Been down so long it looks like up to me'
01/15/02: Confronting terror wherever it occurs
01/09/02: Daschle's war on Bush
01/03/02: Prosperity policies, not partisan politics
12/27/01: Governments create calamity, markets get the blame
12/18/01: 'Tis the season for Daschle to compromise
12/12/01: Hard choices made simple
12/05/01: Straight talk on Iraq
11/28/01: Not all tax cuts are created equal
11/20/01: Words have consequences
11/15/01: Deflationary recession
11/07/01: Consider Mideast reality in the war on terrorism
10/30/01: No 'stimulus' required
10/23/01: Good out of evil
10/16/01: Watching Iraq
10/12/01: The putrid stench of evil
10/04/01: Trade, terror and truth
10/01/01: Drive this scourge from the face of the Earth
09/25/01: Bush emerges as leader for his time
09/06/01: Middle East Madness has a chief instigator
08/30/01: It's about economic growth, stupid!
08/22/01: Phlebotomizers at the IMF
08/17/01: The Greenspan Recession
08/08/01: From Kyoto to Bonn, no science equals nonsense
07/25/01: Fiddling while the world economy freezes
07/19/01: Schundler should be New Jersey's next governor
07/12/01: Second wind for the global economy
07/06/01: An interest-rate target with no bull's-eye
06/28/01: Tax harmonization --- American-style
06/21/01: Warming diplomacy --- at what price?
06/13/01: A party that stands for nothing deserves to lose
06/07/01: No peace in the Middle East
05/30/01: Jeffords' palace coup
05/24/01: A supply-side energy plan
05/16/01: Getting Lincoln right
05/10/01: A good reason to borrow
05/01/01: Supreme Court makes racial profiling the law of the land
04/26/01: Campaign finance reform: silencing the lambs
04/17/01: Right wanted might in China case
04/12/01: How minority entrepreneurs can save the tax cut
04/04/01: Whose privacy is it?
03/29/01: A letter from Seoul
03/20/01: Ignore the double talk and double the tax cuts
03/13/01: Don't give up the bully pulpit on Social Security, Mr. President
03/06/01: Another attack on the economy
02/28/01: It's time to end deflation
02/21/01: Building blocks of humanity
02/15/01: Trumping the propaganda
02/06/01: The Gipper at 90
01/30/01: Kicking off a season of economic growth
01/24/01: The Bush tax agenda
01/17/01: Debating the Clinton legacy
01/10/01: No need for another Social Security commission
01/03/01: Truly a Golden Age, if we can keep it
12/27/00: The Grinch who turned off the holiday lights
12/20/00: Forging ahead
12/13/00: A new tax system for the 21st Century
12/07/00: Global government in retreat
11/30/00: An open letter to Fed Chairman Alan Greenspan
11/21/00: Don't forget the guy in charge
11/15/00: Civic virtue, civic vice
11/08/00: Memo to the president-elect
10/31/00: Scare tactics won't work
10/24/00: Prosperity in the balance
10/11/00: Al Gore's economics of fear
10/03/00: Al Gore IS debatable
09/27/00: Government should protect our online privacy
09/13/00: The most important issue
09/05/00: Defeating the Gore blitz
08/29/00: Workers of the world, rejoice
08/22/00: Just the facts, Mr. President
08/08/00: Reclaiming Lincoln's legacy
06/23/00: A renaissance for urban America?
06/16/00: Capital access can bridge 'digital divide'
06/08/00: Some friendly advice for Rick Lazio
05/26/00: Is the economy being saved or destroyed?
05/22/00: Immigration and the promise that is America
05/12/00: Stock market roulette or snobbery?
05/04/00: Is Rule of Law whatever we say it is?
05/01/00: Myths happen

© 2002, Copley News Service