Jewish World Review Jan. 22, 2002 / 9 Shevat, 5762

Jack Kemp

Jack Kemp
JWR's Pundits
World Editorial
Cartoon Showcase

Mallard Fillmore

Michael Barone
Mona Charen
Linda Chavez
Ann Coulter
Greg Crosby
Larry Elder
Don Feder
Suzanne Fields
Paul Greenberg
Bob Greene
Betsy Hart
Nat Hentoff
David Horowitz
Marianne Jennings
Michael Kelly
Mort Kondracke
Ch. Krauthammer
Lawrence Kudlow
Dr. Laura
John Leo
David Limbaugh
Michelle Malkin
Chris Matthews
Michael Medved
Kathleen Parker
Wes Pruden
Sam Schulman
Amity Shlaes
Tony Snow
Thomas Sowell
Cal Thomas
Jonathan S. Tobin
Ben Wattenberg
George Will
Bruce Williams
Walter Williams
Mort Zuckerman

Consumer Reports

'Been down so long it looks like up to me' -- WIDESPREAD talk of an imminent and robust economic recovery is now being tempered by the sobering reality that the economy is far from out of the woods, and the recovery, when it finally does arrive, may well be rather lackluster. On Jan. 11, Fed Chairman Alan Greenspan announced, "It is still premature to conclude that the forces restraining economic activity here and abroad have abated enough to allow a steady recovery to take hold," which is Greenspanese for, "Whoa, hold your horses." Economic statistics suggest that the economy remains in a deflationary contraction. Despite the hype about a so-called "V-shaped" recovery, the only "V" in sight is the rebound from 9-11 to the depressed level we were at the day before.

Now comes Sen. Ted Kennedy with the strangest idea I've heard since Senate Democratic Leader Tom Daschle said two weeks ago that President George W. Bush's tax cut caused the recession and is making it worse by creating a deficit. But give Kennedy credit for honesty; he says forthrightly what Daschle won't say, namely that we should increase taxes.

If Kennedy wants to repudiate his brother President John F. Kennedy's legacy of cutting tax rates across the board to get America moving again, I think someone should defend that heritage. Maybe Bush should challenge Kennedy to a debate: Kennedy can defend his thesis that tax cuts created the recession, are making it worse by creating a deficit and that a tax increase is the solution to reviving the economy. Bush could defend the thesis of Presidents Kennedy and Ronald Reagan that recessions create deficits, that across-the-board tax rate reductions get the economy growing again and turn deficits into surpluses.

The problem with Kennedy's argument is that it confuses tax rates with tax revenues. He makes a fundamental error that his brother John did not make in 1960-61 when he urged the Congress to cut tax rates across the board by 30 percent. Congress did finally cut tax rates, and revenues increased, which proved President Kennedy right when he said:"It is a paradoxical truth that tax rates are too high today and tax revenues are too low, and the soundest way to raise the revenues in the long run is to cut the rates now. The purpose of cutting taxes now is not to incur a budget deficit, but to achieve the more prosperous, expanding economy which can bring a budget surplus."

Ted Kennedy and Tom Daschle are not alone in their confusion; most analysts remain perplexed about the economy. Washington Post columnist Michael Kelly wrote recently that "Most economists don't understand this peculiar recession especially well. We know this because most of them didn't predict it, which wasn't surprising because most didn't understand the preceding boom, either."

Amidst the confusion, however, a small group -- Brian Wesbury, Larry Kudlow, David Malpass, Alan Reynolds, David Gitlitz, George Gilder, Richard Rahn, Lawrence Hunter, Jude Wanniski and I -- got it right, both on the boom and on the recession. In retrospect, this group had a pretty good understanding that the economic boom sprang from an unleashing of investment, risk-taking and productivity growth made possible by tax rate reductions, tariff reductions, deregulation, government spending restraint and the blossoming of the Internet and other advances in high tech.

We also debunked the prevailing myth of the era that the boom was a mixture of "fiscal discipline" and "irrational exuberance." We never bought the nonsense that "fiscal discipline," aka tax increases and debt reduction, lowered interest rates and produced the only "legitimate" increases in investment.

Nor did we believe that irrational euphoria and blind greed misdirected markets and inflated the economy into a speculative bubble of "extravagant" investment, causing the economy to grow "too fast" and the stock market to fly "too high." And we repeatedly warned, to the point of making pests of ourselves, that Greenspan would bring the new economy crashing down if he persisted in a deflationary monetary policy grounded in these myths.

In retrospect, this cadre of folks can claim some measure of credit for having demonstrated insight and foresight on the economy that most analysts lacked. That surely doesn't entitle them to have their opinions accepted without question in the future, but it should earn for them a special hearing today as they offer opinions on what it will take to restore growth and prosperity, not only to this country but also to the entire world. The recession is a global recession, and it was created by deflationary monetary policy here in the United States.

To ensure a robust economic recovery, the Fed must change its operating procedure and stop targeting interest rates -- before it gets them all the way to zero without solving the problem as happened in Japan - and begin using a commodity price rule to reverse the deflation. Congress and the administration must cut tax rates across the board even more than they did last year, cut the capital gains tax rate and reform the tax code to remove the tax penalties on work, saving, investing and risk-taking to get the economy moving and restore surpluses.

As for the Kennedy brothers, history demonstrates that John was right and Ted is wrong.

Jack Kemp is co-director of Empower America and Distinguished Fellow of the Competitive Enterprise Institute. Comment by clicking here.


01/15/02: Confronting terror wherever it occurs
01/09/02: Daschle's war on Bush
01/03/02: Prosperity policies, not partisan politics
12/27/01: Governments create calamity, markets get the blame
12/18/01: 'Tis the season for Daschle to compromise
12/12/01: Hard choices made simple
12/05/01: Straight talk on Iraq
11/28/01: Not all tax cuts are created equal
11/20/01: Words have consequences
11/15/01: Deflationary recession
11/07/01: Consider Mideast reality in the war on terrorism
10/30/01: No 'stimulus' required
10/23/01: Good out of evil
10/16/01: Watching Iraq
10/12/01: The putrid stench of evil
10/04/01: Trade, terror and truth
10/01/01: Drive this scourge from the face of the Earth
09/25/01: Bush emerges as leader for his time
09/06/01: Middle East Madness has a chief instigator
08/30/01: It's about economic growth, stupid!
08/22/01: Phlebotomizers at the IMF
08/17/01: The Greenspan Recession
08/08/01: From Kyoto to Bonn, no science equals nonsense
07/25/01: Fiddling while the world economy freezes
07/19/01: Schundler should be New Jersey's next governor
07/12/01: Second wind for the global economy
07/06/01: An interest-rate target with no bull's-eye
06/28/01: Tax harmonization --- American-style
06/21/01: Warming diplomacy --- at what price?
06/13/01: A party that stands for nothing deserves to lose
06/07/01: No peace in the Middle East
05/30/01: Jeffords' palace coup
05/24/01: A supply-side energy plan
05/16/01: Getting Lincoln right
05/10/01: A good reason to borrow
05/01/01: Supreme Court makes racial profiling the law of the land
04/26/01: Campaign finance reform: silencing the lambs
04/17/01: Right wanted might in China case
04/12/01: How minority entrepreneurs can save the tax cut
04/04/01: Whose privacy is it?
03/29/01: A letter from Seoul
03/20/01: Ignore the double talk and double the tax cuts
03/13/01: Don't give up the bully pulpit on Social Security, Mr. President
03/06/01: Another attack on the economy
02/28/01: It's time to end deflation
02/21/01: Building blocks of humanity
02/15/01: Trumping the propaganda
02/06/01: The Gipper at 90
01/30/01: Kicking off a season of economic growth
01/24/01: The Bush tax agenda
01/17/01: Debating the Clinton legacy
01/10/01: No need for another Social Security commission
01/03/01: Truly a Golden Age, if we can keep it
12/27/00: The Grinch who turned off the holiday lights
12/20/00: Forging ahead
12/13/00: A new tax system for the 21st Century
12/07/00: Global government in retreat
11/30/00: An open letter to Fed Chairman Alan Greenspan
11/21/00: Don't forget the guy in charge
11/15/00: Civic virtue, civic vice
11/08/00: Memo to the president-elect
10/31/00: Scare tactics won't work
10/24/00: Prosperity in the balance
10/11/00: Al Gore's economics of fear
10/03/00: Al Gore IS debatable
09/27/00: Government should protect our online privacy
09/13/00: The most important issue
09/05/00: Defeating the Gore blitz
08/29/00: Workers of the world, rejoice
08/22/00: Just the facts, Mr. President
08/08/00: Reclaiming Lincoln's legacy
06/23/00: A renaissance for urban America?
06/16/00: Capital access can bridge 'digital divide'
06/08/00: Some friendly advice for Rick Lazio
05/26/00: Is the economy being saved or destroyed?
05/22/00: Immigration and the promise that is America
05/12/00: Stock market roulette or snobbery?
05/04/00: Is Rule of Law whatever we say it is?
05/01/00: Myths happen

© 2002, Copley News Service