Jewish World Review August 18, 2004 /1 Elul, 5764

Edward I. Koch

JWR's Pundits
World Editorial
Cartoon Showcase

Mallard Fillmore

Michael Barone
Mona Charen
Linda Chavez
Ann Coulter
Greg Crosby
Larry Elder
Don Feder
Suzanne Fields
James Glassman
Paul Greenberg
Bob Greene
Betsy Hart
Nat Hentoff
David Horowitz
Marianne Jennings
Michael Kelly
Mort Kondracke
Ch. Krauthammer
Lawrence Kudlow
Dr. Laura
John Leo
Michelle Malkin
Jackie Mason
Chris Matthews
Michael Medved
Kathleen Parker
Wes Pruden
Sam Schulman
Amity Shlaes
Roger Simon
Tony Snow
Thomas Sowell
Cal Thomas
Jonathan S. Tobin
Ben Wattenberg
George Will
Bruce Williams
Walter Williams
Mort Zuckerman

Consumer Reports

Anti-Bush demonstrators know they can help re-elect prez | The Republican National Convention will take place in New York City from August 30 to September 2. Demonstrators will picket and denounce the delegates assembled to designate George W. Bush as the Republican nominee for reelection. But those who expect a repeat of the riots that occurred during the 1968 Democratic National Convention will be disappointed. It won't happen.

Demonstrators know that riot scenes on TV would only add to a Bush margin of victory. The country is divided on many issues, e.g., same-sex marriage, stem-cell research, death penalty, abortion, Iraq, to name just a few, with each side claiming the moral high ground. Overwhelmingly, voters believe those issues should be decided at the ballot box and not by violence.

Violence also will be curtailed by law enforcement. New York City has a well-trained police force of nearly 40,000 and a superb police commissioner in Ray Kelly who will use the forces at his command to make certain that those bent on violence are frustrated in their efforts and arrested. I believe that every person who commits an act of violence should receive and serve jail time, the length of which should depend on the nature and extent of the violence. The rights of demonstrators to be heard and seen by their quarry also will be protected and enforced by the police. The rights of the delegates to perform their functions at the convention will, likewise, be safeguarded.

We are fortunate at this time in the city's history to have a mayor whose hallmark is civility and respect for others. He has shown from his first days in office that he will talk and listen to all who wish to be heard, so long as they too are civil and respectful of the rights of others while making their arguments.

New York City has always been the home of demonstrations. When I was Mayor, sometimes there were pickets for different causes circling City Hall at the same time. Some demonstrators even slept in City Hall Park. I recall greeting these people at 7:30 a.m. as I entered the building.

Some demonstrators may resort to non-violent civil disobedience. Acts of civil disobedience have included marching without a permit, blocking traffic, declining to identify oneself to a police officer when stopped for alleged illegal activity and many similar acts. We have a statue in Union Square Park honoring Mahatma Gandhi, father of the concept of non-violent civil disobedience. The statue was erected by the Department of Parks & Recreation during my administration. Those who choose to commit acts of civil disobedience should know they do so at their own risk and may be prosecuted. In my view, non-violent acts of civil disobedience that violate the law should be subject to civil fines, escalating with each new act of civil disobedience committed by the same person in the same protest. I believe the first conviction should carry a $250 fine, the second $500, the third a $1,000 and ever higher. There will be violators who expect no fines, pleading their morality and high purpose, and no different than the protagonist in the hoary story of the axe murderer of his two parents who, when asked for a final word before sentencing, said, "Your honor, please, sir, be merciful, I'm an orphan."

Donate to JWR

If history is a guide, there are judges who will attempt to get rid of criminal cases against protestors quickly by dismissing them in the "interest of justice" or imposing the lightest of sentences. These judges should know that their spinelessness will only encourage the same violators and their supporters to commit other unlawful acts.

Now to the cops. I have said that they are well trained and they are professional. But among 40,000 people, there will always be some miscreants who will disgrace their uniforms and, worse still, damage the reputation of their fellow officers who are doing a good job.

The Mayor's office, police officers' and firefighters' unions have been at odds currently during labor negotiations. The New York Times reports, "'The level of frustration is so high,' said Stephen J. Cassidy, the president of the Uniformed Firefighters Association, 'I can't account for what might happen' during the convention. When asked repeatedly if the two groups would consider striking or taking other labor actions, Patrick J. Lynch, president of the Patrolmen's Benevolent Association, said, 'We will not rule out anything.'" These threats alone violate both the Taylor Law barring municipal strikes and an agreement signed by all unions, including the municipal unions, to refrain from convention-related strikes. If they continue with these actions or strike in any form, the mayor should seek Taylor Law penalties and an injunction which, if violated, could precipitate huge fines against the unions' treasuries and an end to the union dues check-off.

Recently, The New York Times reports that following a community meeting, some police officers threatened the Mayor's press secretary with shouts of "Eddie, we know where you live." The individuals who threatened the press secretary should be arrested and tried in the criminal courts and in police administrative tribunals and, upon conviction, cashiered — permanently removed from the police force. In some third world countries, the police have adopted criminal behavior. We will not tolerate that happening in New York City. The Police Department should not hesitate to call in the F.B.I. to assist them in identifying these officers. The best way, of course, would be for the honest and professional members of the police force to turn them in. I hope they do so and are properly rewarded.

In closing let me say we want everyone — delegates, demonstrators, police officers and every other New Yorker to have a wonderful time during the convention. Everyone should know that both delegates and demonstrators will have their liberties protected in New York City; the former to select their candidate; the latter to express their opposition. That's America and that's New York City.

Minnie the Elephant and I recently did a commercial reminding everyone, "The Republicans are coming, make nice." At the end of the convention Minnie and I are expecting to celebrate the success of our efforts. So everybody involved, please — make nice.

Every weekday publishes what many in Washington and in the media consider "must reading." Sign up for the daily JWR update. It's free. Just click here.

JWR contributor Edward I. Koch, the former mayor of New York, can be heard on Bloomberg Radio (WBBR 1130 AM) every Sunday from 9-10 am . Comment by clicking here.

08/12/04: I've been branded a ‘turncoat’
07/28/04: If everyone is deemed responsible, no one is responsible
07/20/04: Why Bush must win
07/14/04: The crass class
07/07/04: Potpourri
06/29/04: Moore is an irresponsible propagandist who would have denounced WW II, too
06/16/04: Behind every hero
06/08/04: Reagan's afterlife on Earth
05/19/04: We should not be pleading with the U.N. for help — we should be demanding it
05/12/04: Abu Ghraib will go away but Rummy — and Bush — shouldn't
04/20/04: Freedom of what?
03/03/04: Wake-up call: Prez will be defeated if he doesn't take action to stop other dangerous attack
03/12/04: Yes, Jews do engage in anti-Semitic behavior
02/04/04: History will judge Bush favorably
01/28/04: Why the President was justified — David Kay or not
01/15/04: It is not compassionate or intelligent to open our borders to all
12/24/03: Why I'm voting for Bush
11/26/03: Appeasement only whets the appetite of aggressors
11/06/03: Putin's prosecution of the oligarchs can teach a powerful lesson about anti-Semitism
07/30/03: As the world churns
07/23/03: America not so different than Russia in pursuing white collar criminals
07/16/03: Dems, media are making an unforgivable mistake
06/18/03: Keep American troops out of Israel
05/22/03: It's lots of fun to remain relevant
05/14/03: Living up to their mascot's image? Dems attacks on prez are backfiring
05/07/03: Wall Street settlement was not justice
04/16/03: The doves were proven wrong. Instead of conceding defeat, they are throwing another political tantrum
04/09/03: As the world churns
04/03/03: Gulf War II: The misleading media does it again
03/18/03: Have the courage to admit it, Pat: You're a classic anti-Semite who gives conservatives a bad name
03/12/03: "There they go again"? Not quite!
03/05/03: Making the case for war on British TV left some panelists stunned
02/20/03: Death penalty=racism? Don't confuse them with the facts
02/12/03: History is now repeating itself --- why don't the American bashers grasp it?
02/05/03: As the world turns
01/30/03: Why are sports exempt from racial diversity and universities encouraged to engage in racial preferences over individual academic achievement?
01/23/03: We absolutely can't back down
11/13/02: President blunted the Ted Kennedys of Democrat party --- good for him!
10/23/02: New Jersey's bigot laureate is no private citizen and his 'defenses' are idiotic
10/01/02: Congress is not doing its job
09/26/02: Confronting pathetic Americans in a post 9-11 world
09/19/02: Don't be fooled by Saddam
09/05/02: Necessary or not, getting congressional approval for war is common-sense
08/28/02: In defense of terrorism
08/22/02: Saddam Hussein is extremely popular in "Arab street," so why attack him?
08/15/02: My potpourri
08/09/02: Traitors: Journalistic and 'patriotic'
07/31/02: Euros should spend their time analyzing their own country's wartime actions
07/25/02: I may know next to nothing about the stock market, but I'm not getting out
07/18/02: Dems should stop trying to 'Whitewater' the President
07/11/02: Real Americans and the Islamic threat

© 2002, Edward I. Koch