Jewish World Review May 12, 2004 /20 Iyar, 5764

Edward I. Koch

JWR's Pundits
World Editorial
Cartoon Showcase

Mallard Fillmore

Michael Barone
Mona Charen
Linda Chavez
Ann Coulter
Greg Crosby
Larry Elder
Don Feder
Suzanne Fields
James Glassman
Paul Greenberg
Bob Greene
Betsy Hart
Nat Hentoff
David Horowitz
Marianne Jennings
Michael Kelly
Mort Kondracke
Ch. Krauthammer
Lawrence Kudlow
Dr. Laura
John Leo
Michelle Malkin
Jackie Mason
Chris Matthews
Michael Medved
Kathleen Parker
Wes Pruden
Sam Schulman
Amity Shlaes
Roger Simon
Tony Snow
Thomas Sowell
Cal Thomas
Jonathan S. Tobin
Ben Wattenberg
George Will
Bruce Williams
Walter Williams
Mort Zuckerman

Consumer Reports

Abu Ghraib will go away but Rummy — and Bush — shouldn't | Is defense secretary Donald Rumsfeld a liability to President Bush's chances of reelection? I believe not, but I've been wrong before.

Yes, Rumsfeld is responsible, as he himself acknowledged at the Senate hearings on May 7th. However, I don't believe he should be forced to resign. There has been no charge that he ordered the mistreatment in Iraq or elsewhere or was or should have been aware it was taking place. The key question then is what did he do about the prisoner abuse once he knew about it?

According to Rumsfeld's testimony before committees of the United States Senate and House of Representatives, the Pentagon made public on January 16, 2004 that a criminal investigation was opened on prisoner abuses in Abu Ghraib. That, apparently, was when Rumsfeld became aware of the charges. Thereafter, there were a number of Pentagon announcements making the charges public and announcing criminal investigations and reports. Interestingly, they were not picked up by the media, other than briefly.

To reiterate, the judgment to be made by the public is, did Rumsfeld take appropriate measures to deal with the abuses once he learned of them? The same question must be asked about the actions or inactions of everyone in the chain of command from those in the prison committing the atrocities to those supervisors responsible for the safety of Iraqi prisoners to their supervisors at central command.

Those who failed to take appropriate action when they knew or should have known of the abuses deserve to be severely punished. If appropriate action was taken by Rumsfeld and his top generals in charge, including Generals Ricardo S. Sanchez and Richard B. Myers, Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, then demanding they be removed from their positions is simply playing politics in the hope that it will detrimentally impact on President George W. Bush's reelection.

While the polls will rise and fall many times with respect to support or opposition to President Bush, at the time of the writing of this commentary, it does not appear that President Bush has lost the hearts and minds of America's citizens and maintains a lead over Senator Kerry. Why is that?

Donate to JWR

One set of reasons is that people generally trust the President's fundamental decency and have concluded that when it comes to national security, Bush and the Republican Party are far more reliable than Kerry and the Democratic Party. Voters apparently do not emotionally connect with Kerry. A New York Times article recently reported that he is seeking to move to the political center. It won't wash.

My close friends are overwhelmingly liberal: After all, I live in New York City. Everyone knows that I have always described myself as a liberal with sanity. When I asked a group of ten close friends, "Who is voting for Bush?" in addition to me, one or two raised their hands. All the others said they were voting for Kerry. When I asked who they thought would win irrespective of who they personally were supporting, invariably they all said Bush.

America bows its head in shame because of the horrors a small number of their fellow Americans visited upon Iraqi prisoners. The actions of those few — the exact number is yet to be determined — has disgusted the American people. In recent years, Americans, civilian and military, have been the subjects of barbarism, torture, kidnappings and death by Arab insurgents and terrorists. The gruesome sight of four American civilians killed in Fallujah, two of whom were hanged from a bridge and set on fire posthumously, enraged Americans.

Yet, there are very few Americans who would defend the criminal acts and war crimes committed in Abu Ghraib on the basis of revenge. No excuse for what took place there is acceptable to most Americans.

On the other hand, the people around the Arab world overwhelmingly cheered the killings of the near 3,000 innocents in the World Trade Center and the dragging of the dead bodies of American soldiers through the streets of Mogadishu, Somalia. Those same multitudes applauded the point-blank execution of a pregnant Israeli mother and her four infant daughters riding in a car in Gaza.

Our society condemns barbarism and savagery. We do not confer martyr status on those who kill or torture others, particularly innocent people. To the contrary, our society demands such miscreants be punished. I believe Rumsfeld is innocent of any departure from the legitimate rules of war and should not resign, provided he does what I am certain he will do — identify the guilty and seek appropriate punishment for them.

According to The New York Times, "A new poll showed that most people thought that Mr. Rumsfeld should not lose his job over the issue. Asked whether he should resign, two-thirds of 1,030 people questioned… said Mr. Rumsfeld should not resign."

Every weekday publishes what many in Washington and in the media consider "must reading." Sign up for the daily JWR update. It's free. Just click here.

JWR contributor Edward I. Koch, the former mayor of New York, can be heard on Bloomberg Radio (WBBR 1130 AM) every Saturday from 9-10 am. Comment by clicking here.

04/20/04: Freedom of … what?
03/03/04: Wake-up call: Prez will be defeated if he doesn't take action to stop other dangerous attack
03/12/04: Yes, Jews do engage in anti-Semitic behavior
02/04/04: History will judge Bush favorably
01/28/04: Why the President was justified — David Kay or not
01/15/04: It is not compassionate or intelligent to open our borders to all
12/24/03: Why I'm voting for Bush
11/26/03: Appeasement only whets the appetite of aggressors
11/06/03: Putin's prosecution of the oligarchs can teach a powerful lesson about anti-Semitism
07/30/03: As the world churns
07/23/03: America not so different than Russia in pursuing white collar criminals
07/16/03: Dems, media are making an unforgivable mistake
06/18/03: Keep American troops out of Israel
05/22/03: It's lots of fun to remain relevant
05/14/03: Living up to their mascot's image? Dems attacks on prez are backfiring
05/07/03: Wall Street settlement was not justice
04/16/03: The doves were proven wrong. Instead of conceding defeat, they are throwing another political tantrum
04/09/03: As the world churns
04/03/03: Gulf War II: The misleading media does it again
03/18/03: Have the courage to admit it, Pat: You're a classic anti-Semite who gives conservatives a bad name
03/12/03: "There they go again"? Not quite!
03/05/03: Making the case for war on British TV left some panelists stunned
02/20/03: Death penalty=racism? Don't confuse them with the facts
02/12/03: History is now repeating itself --- why don't the American bashers grasp it?
02/05/03: As the world turns
01/30/03: Why are sports exempt from racial diversity and universities encouraged to engage in racial preferences over individual academic achievement?
01/23/03: We absolutely can't back down
11/13/02: President blunted the Ted Kennedys of Democrat party --- good for him!
10/23/02: New Jersey's bigot laureate is no private citizen and his 'defenses' are idiotic
10/01/02: Congress is not doing its job
09/26/02: Confronting pathetic Americans in a post 9-11 world
09/19/02: Don't be fooled by Saddam
09/05/02: Necessary or not, getting congressional approval for war is common-sense
08/28/02: In defense of terrorism
08/22/02: Saddam Hussein is extremely popular in "Arab street," so why attack him?
08/15/02: My potpourri
08/09/02: Traitors: Journalistic and 'patriotic'
07/31/02: Euros should spend their time analyzing their own country's wartime actions
07/25/02: I may know next to nothing about the stock market, but I'm not getting out
07/18/02: Dems should stop trying to 'Whitewater' the President
07/11/02: Real Americans and the Islamic threat

© 2002, Edward I. Koch