Contact The Editor
Articles By This Author
For more than three decades, California and Texas have been like tectonic plates drifting in opposite directions.
California, the ancestral land of Republicans Richard M. Nixon and Ronald Reagan, has become a Democratic stronghold. It's been 20 years since a GOP candidate won statewide office.
Texas, which bred Democratic giants such as Sam Rayburn and Lyndon B. Johnson, has become a Republican fortress. A Democrat hasn't been elected statewide in more than 30 years.
And yet with the midterm election about to enter its final, post-Labor Day sprint, Texas is home to not one but two competitive contests, for governor and U.S. Senate. It's a stark contrast with California, where Democrat Xavier Becerra appears to be a shoo-in for governor and Adam Schiff, in 2024, waltzed into his Senate seat.
There's still plenty of time between now and election day on Nov. 3. Democrats, to their deep consternation, have repeatedly seen their hopes rise, only to crash once Texans actually turn out to vote.
"You don't take anything for granted," said James Aldrete, a Democratic strategist in Austin, who's watched for years as his party wandered fruitlessly in the campaign desert. "But there is beautiful native wildlife that grows in the desert, and it's blooming right now."
The question — for the moment, at least — is why California hasn't budged while Texas has become a surprise battleground.
The answer involves individual personalities, demographics and political headwinds.
Of the two contests, the fight for Texas' open Senate seat appears to be much closer. Election handicappers rate it a toss-up.
The Democrat, state Rep. James Talarico, is a highly gifted campaigner and prodigious fundraiser. But arguably the best thing he has going for his candidacy is his Republican opponent, Atty. Gen. Ken Paxton, whose history of scandal, shady dealings and moral lapses trail him like dirty footprints on a white carpet.
Paxton stomped incumbent John Cornyn, with the help of President Trump, in a vicious GOP primary that left ill will among a number of Republicans. Had Cornyn won, many doubt the Senate seat would be in play.
'A big ask'
In the race for governor, Republican Greg Abbott is facing Democratic state Rep. Gina Hinojosa as he seeks an unprecedented fourth term — "a big ask of voters," in the words of J. Miles Coleman, who analyzes elections at the University of Virginia's Center for Politics. Sabato's Crystal Ball, the center's forecasting project, recently moved the gubernatorial race to "likely Republican," a shift away from "Safe Republican."
Other election handicappers have done the same.
Texas has long fancied itself a place apart; secession is one recurring fantasy. But for all its perceived go-your-own-way independence, the state isn't immune from broader trends, which helps explain why it's suddenly in play.
"One of the external factors that's making Texas competitive is the degree of wind in Democratic sails," said Jim Henson, director of the Texas Politics Project at the University of Texas in Austin.
Whether it's anti-establishment anger, directed at the party in power, or frustration with Trump, his war-making and failure to deliver the sterling economy he promised, "when you think of the problems Republicans are having at the national level ... that's helping Democrats here as well," Henson said.
(Trump's taint is also a problem for California Republican Steve Hilton, running for governor in a state where the president's approval rating rests at the subbasement level.)
By the numbers
Henson, who conducts polling statewide, said another reason Texas is more competitive than California is simple mathematics: "Democrats [haven't] fallen quite as far in Texas as Republicans have in California."
Texas doesn't register voters by party. But weighting political surveys by demographics and following election results, Henson expects about a 10% Republican turnout advantage in November. By contrast, registered Democrats outnumber registered Republicans in California by nearly 2 to 1.
Yet another reason Texas appears to have grown more competitive is the apparent discontent of Latino voters, an increasingly important part of the state's burgeoning electorate.
Though Latinos shifted strongly in Trump's favor in 2024, many have grown disillusioned in the nearly two years since. "They're moving away from both parties," said Mike Madrid, a California strategist who's spent decades studying the Latino vote. "When the environment is bad, they're punishing whatever party is power."
Two years ago, it was Democrats. Now it's Republicans.
In recent years, as the country cleaved, California emerged as the unofficial capital of blue America, offering a political, social and cultural counterweight to Texas, the unofficial capital of red America. The two states anchor the Democratic and Republican parties, respectively, and are key to their financial well-being and the success of their candidates nationwide.
A Democratic toehold in Texas would instantly scramble long-standing political calculations, starting with the 2028 presidential race.
"It changes the narrative. It changes the demographic strategy," Madrid said. "It changes the 270 [electoral college] map. It changes the whole strategy."
In short, a November win would be more than symbolic, or gratification after years of Democratic futility. It would be a political earthquake.
(COMMENT, BELOW)
Mark Z. Barabak
Los Angeles Times/(TNS)
Mark Z. Barabak is a columnist for the Los Angeles Times, focusing on politics in California and the West.
Previously:
• 08/13/26 Dems are at each other's throats --- this time over the 2028 calendar
• 04/07/26 Is California really going to elect a Republican governor? Is there a Democratic Plan B?
• 03/02/25 Gavin Newsom and Kamala Harris have traveled parallel paths. Will they collide in 2028?
• 12/18/25 Is Newsom blazing a path to the White House? Running a fool's errand? Let's discuss
• 12/04/25 What a scandal! (Or not.) How things have changed
• 11/11/25 Nancy Pelosi prided herself on cold calculation. She knew it was time
• 10/03/25 He's a real pain for Gavin Newsom. And a rising Dem star
• 10/01/25 He's a real pain for Gavin Newsom. And a rising Democratic star
• 08/26/25 Power grab may energize Newsom and Dems. But it won't fix their bigger problem
• 07/16/25 He tried to keep Trump from a second term. But six months in, 'I'm very impressed.'
• 06/05/25 Yelling, finger-pointing and cursing galore as California Dems gather near Disneyland
• 05/13/25
Gavin Newsom wants to be president. Not so fast!
• 04/02/25 America has gotten ruder. Starting at the very top
• 03/14/25 Newsom's next step --- to self-destruction
• 12/31/24 History gets Jimma Carter wrong --- both underrated and overrated
• 12/03/24 She's won twice in Trump country. Will the Dems listen to her?
• 11/14/24 Call Adam Schiff what you want. California's next senator is ready to work with Trump
• 11/13/24 America's last presidential bellwether ends its winning streak
• 11/13/23 Overwhelmed? Confused? Here's what to make of all those presidential polls
• 09/18/23 How labor and a wily senator turned Nevada blue --- and redrew the nation's presidential map
• 07/13/23 Here's why California will be the 2024 presidential kingmaker. (Just kidding)
• 06/19/23 Barbara Boxer warns progressives to back off on Dianne Feinstein or they may be sorry
• 06/15/23 He's gay and Republican. And no longer makes apologies
• 05/23/23 Feinstein is not going to quit the Senate. Ever. Just ask her biographer
• 02/07/23 Here's why Joe Biden won't be dumping Kamala Harris as his running mate
• 09/29/22 Is abortion issue a lifeline that saves the Senate for Dems? This race offers a test case
• 07/25/22 Don't underestimate Kamala Harris. She's still the Dem most likely to succeed Biden
• 05/17/22 RINOS V. DINOS: Oregon race a referendum on nation's direction of Dems
• 04/14/22 What if everyone is required to vote? Would that help cure America's political ills?
• 02/18/22 Where's the love? Here's why Kamala Harris' California poll numbers stink
• 02/18/22 From uber-liberal San Fran, school board recall is a three-alarm warning for Dems nationwide
• 12/09/21 So you think Kamala Harris has it rough. Remember Dan Quayle?
• 01/17/13 A RINO in Frisco