The Trial Balloon Fiasco

A sidewinder missile fired from a U.S. Air Force F-22 fighter brings down a 200-foot-diameter balloon off the coast of South Carolina. U.S. Navy and Coast Guard aircraft and vessels are dispatched to search for and recover debris in the storm-tossed Atlantic Ocean. In Beijing, spokesmen for the People's Republic of China insist the "airship," which coasted over U.S. territory for more than a week, was nothing but a harmless weather balloon, inadvertently blown over the United States by unanticipated wind currents. In Washington, comments by government officials — most of them nameless — range from "don't worry, this happens all the time" to "this is a major, perhaps existential threat to the American people." At the White House, the seriously compromised president of the U.S. searches for ways to blame his predecessor for an unprecedented breach of U.S. airspace and the ensuing media circus.

If I wrote the paragraph above in opening a novel or as a "pitch" treatment for a TV mini-series, the Writers Guild could well revoke my membership. And my publishing editor would remind me a novel requires "the willful suspension of disbelief" and "what you wrote is too unbelievable to be real."

All this — and more — confirm truth really is "stranger than fiction" and truth is hard to find in Beijing or Washington. So, I decided to call some trusted friends — also nameless — from my years on Ronald Reagan's National Security Council staff and since. Here are a few of my questions and their answers:

Q. Was this balloon a "one-off," a mistake, or a deliberate provocation?

A. The "balloon," as you call it, is a sophisticated, intelligence surveillance and collection platform. Communist China has been employing devices like this for years over and near Taiwan and other countries including Russia, Japan, Vietnam, the Philippines, the Korean peninsula, South and Central America and Guam, to name a few. The only thing the PRC could have done to make this event more provocative would have been to make the balloon out of bright red spectra with a big, bold, gold star on it.

SIGN UP FOR THE DAILY JWR UPDATE. IT'S FREE. Just click here.

Q. Why would the PRC use balloons when they have satellites?

A. Spy balloons are a lot cheaper to build and launch than satellites. Visual and radar imagery from a balloon at 65,000 to 70,000 feet offers far better resolution than that from satellites orbiting hundreds of miles above earth. With the right sensors aboard, spy balloons can collect info from every cellphone over hundreds of thousands of square miles. Place an order for fast food in Montana and folks in Beijing will know who you are, where you are and what you're having for lunch.

Q. Are claims about Chinese spy balloons overflying the U.S. during the Trump administration and crashing off Hawaii true?

A. Every Trump-era official I know from DoD, State (Department), the intel community and DHS deny knowing about such events. But if they did occur, someone in those agencies better have a great explanation as to why they were not passed up the chain of command.

Q. Was shooting it down the right thing to do?

A. Yes. But it should have been brought down over the Aleutian Islands or Alaska where there is very little risk to people from falling debris. Had the Pentagon brought it down with guns instead of blowing it up with a missile, exploitation would have been much easier.

Q. What's the most valuable info the PRC would be able to gather from this balloon?

A. It's not about locating missile silos or even the telemetry of our NORAD radars. The most valuable info they gained from this event is watching the reaction of our commander in chief and the response of the American people.

As We the People witnessed in the Afghanistan retreat debacle, our president is once again seen to be confused, uncertain and vacillating — traits inviting aggression from despots.

(COMMENT, BELOW)

Previously:
• 02/01/23 Prepare for War to Avoid Having to Fight One
• 01/17/23 Mission No. 1 for the US House of Representatives: US National Security
• 01/17/23 To the 118th Congress: Welcome Aboard. Now Get to Work -- Part II
• 01/03/23 To the 118th Congress: Welcome Aboard. Now Get to Work -- Part I
• 12/13/22 Bad Decisions from a Floundering President
• 12/05/22 Ignoring Lessons Learned at Pearl Harbor
• 11/29/22 'Prep-Fire' for the 118th Congress
• 11/22/22 Thanksgiving 2022
• 11/15/22 Now What, Mr. Biden?
• 10/19/22 At the Edge of Winter --- A Crucial Contest
• 10/25/22 Adapt and Overcome
• 10/14/22 Biden's Treasonous Troika
• 10/06/22 We the People Must Exert Our Authority "
• 09/28/22 Biden's Bumbling and Stumbling Could Start WWIII
• 09/20/22 Is Our Military Prepared for Another 9/11 Attack?
• 09/13/22 Are 'MAGA Republicans' Fascists?
• 09/07/22 Biden's Strategy For Ukraine: Don't Win
• 08/30/22 The Hidden Costs of Biden's Student Loan Debacle
• 08/23/22 Afghanistan: One Year Later
• 08/23/22 Freedom or Totalitarianism --- Which Will 'We the People' Choose?
• 08/09/22 Do You Support Joe Biden's Solution for High Gas Prices?
• 08/02/22 Why Military Enlistments Are Plummeting
• 07/19/22 Dem Lies and GOP Responses
• 07/12/22 Are You Watching the Jan. 6 Hearings?
• 07/04/22 July 4, 1776: Sacrificing for Freedom
• 06/28/22 Are Dems Still the Party of Human Bondage?
• 06/21/22 Biden's Open Door to Criminals, Drug Pushers and Human traffickers
• 06/14/22 Do Dems Want Conservative Justices To Be Murdered?
• 05/31/22 Memorial Day Salute 2022
• 05/24/22 Biden's Barbarity: Violence Is the New Normal
• 05/17/22 Assault on the Sanctity of Human Life
• 05/10/22 The Price America Is Paying for Rejecting the Lord
• 05/03/22 Orwellian Common Ground: Hitler, Stalin, Putin and Biden
• 04/26/22 The Biden Regime Is Wrecking America
• 04/19/22 Biden's Family Scandal: Never Underestimate the Power of Blackmail
• 04/12/22 Biden's Deadly Energy Policy
• 04/05/22 Biden's 'New World Order'
• 03/22/22 Is the Spirit of 1776 Dead in America?
• 03/15/22 Ukraine's Plan B -- As in 'Berlin'
• 03/08/22 Biden's SOTU Strategy: Ignore, Distort and Co-opt
• 03/08/22 Durham Probe: What Did Hillary Know and When Did She Know It?
• 02/15/21 Blatant Hypocrisy: Uyghur Flag-Bearer for China's Olympic Team
• 02/01/21 Woke Policies Kill Cops
• 02/01/21 Victimhood: Favorite Status of the Left
• 01/25/21 Foreign Policy Review: Biden's Disastrous First Year at the Helm
• 01/11/21 Is Communist China Colonizing Cuba?
• 12/28/21 Dem 'Leaders' Fail the Leadership Test
• 12/28/21: New Year's Resolutions for 2022
• 12/16 /21: While Biden Slept: Appeasement and Accommodation
• 07/01/21 Fatherless Children --- The Progressive-Democrat Nightmare