Jewish World Review July 18, 2003 / 18 Tamuz, 5763
The irascible, bigoted Harry Truman was a product of his times
Richard Cohen, Washington Post columnist,
has been provoked by recent revelations about President Harry Truman to
asseverate in all his comely humility that "It is ... a good thing that he
(Truman) did not express his feelings to someone like me, because had the
Secret Service not been around I would have decked him."
Poor Harry, what did he say all those years ago that brings the
he-man out of this otherwise exquisite moral conscience?
History is the greatest of the humanities. To remind us of its
consequentiality it leaves specimens of itself around for later generations
to discover to their amazement and edification. The other day, Cohen along
with millions of other Americans, discovered a specimen of the first half of
the last century, when the contents of a hitherto undiscovered diary from
1947 was made public by the National Archives.
The 5,500-word diary was in the handwriting of President Truman.
It had been found scrawled in the diary section of a book that had been
gathering dust in the Truman Library for decades, and rightly so. The book's
title is, alas, "The Real Estate Board of New York, Inc., Diary and Manual
1947." Not surprisingly, visiting historians dismissed it as an old
reference book, devoid of much value to them in their reconstructions of
Truman. They were thunderously wrong.
The diary section can be read as a personal confession from the
president to his mother or perhaps to a sympathetic friend seated with him
at the end of the bar. In smoldering dudgeon, the 33rd president opined,
"The Jews have no sense of proportion nor do they have any judgement (a
popular spelling in the 1940s) on world affairs."
He had been provoked by a call he had received from his Jewish
former secretary of the treasury, Henry Morgenthau. Morgenthau was seeking
Truman's assistance on behalf of a group of Jewish refugees from Hitler's
Europe. That irritated Truman.
"The Jews, I find are very, very selfish. They care not how many
Estonians, Latvians, Finns, Poles, Yugoslavs or Greeks get murdered or
mistreated as D(isplaced) P(ersons). ..." And the president's rant went on
to embrace other matters, "When the country went backward and
Republican in the election of 1946, this incident (another occasion when
Morgenthau assisted Jewish refugees) loomed large on the D(isplaced)
Americans have come to admire Harry Truman as a flinty defender
of American interests. He was a doughty combatant and a very good president,
at least in foreign affairs. Not surprisingly, we have forgotten just how
much controversy his administration found itself in.
He was apparently honest, but nearly a dozen members of his
government were convicted of criminal behavior, including his appointments
secretary. He was also a fiery partisan. Readers of his very informative
memoirs will note that he has rarely a generous word for those who oppose
him. His remark, that "the country went backward" in 1946, is typical. In
his memoirs, he lumps isolationists such as Sen. Robert Taft in with Ku
Kluxers and members of the far-right Silver Shirts and he was not being
facetious. To him, most Republicans were reactionaries, and he was not any
gentler toward those political parties on his left.
The New York Sun has published specimens of his prejudices
against other ethnic and religious groups for instance, the Chinese and
"Japs" whom he told his wife he "hate(ed)." Blacks, "wops" and others came
off no better in his private reflections. When I read these outbursts, I was
at first startled, but then I thought back about the America of the early
20th century. Its citizens almost all had strong prejudices.
An important thing to remember is that America has changed. Few
people hold such strong beliefs today, even in private. What is more,
Truman's generation began an effort to mollify such prejudices and to extend
tolerance to all. As for Truman, his public policies favored equal rights
and statehood for Israel. Those policies were not easily implemented.
History proceeds slowly.
The irascible, bigoted Harry Truman that again stands revealed
in this long-ignored specimen of history brings to mind another truth that,
since the political battles of the 1990s, I have become very aware of.
Political commitment breeds anger and animosity. The 33rd president was for
all his faults a decent man, but like most politically committed people he
came to dislike and distrust those who opposed him. In the 1940s, he could
become very angry with Morgenthau for the former secretary of state's
importunities on behalf of Jewish refugees. In reading his memoirs, you will
see he had an even more intense ire for Republicans. Naturally, Republicans
had the same view of him. Politics breeds contempt.
In the 1990s, a president was caught in obvious ethical and
legal violations. What saved him was the mutual contempt the political
parties hold for each other. Hillary Rodham Clinton's memoirs are as angry
toward Republicans as were Truman's, and you can be sure if Newt Gingrich
ever quiets down long enough to produce a memoir, he will match them both in
Harry Truman is not the only politician made angry by politics.
A more intriguing point for me would be to know how many members of the
political class enter politics free of anger. In my experience, the only one
I knew who seemed to be free of anger was Ronald Reagan, for whom Richard
Cohen has few charitable thoughts.
Enjoy this writer's work? Why not sign-up for the daily JWR update. It's free. Just click here.
JWR contributor Bob Tyrrell is editor in chief of The American Spectator. Comment by clicking here.
07/11/03: A grand affair of hot colors and surprisingly sedate audience participation
07/04/03: In search of anti-Americanism and the perfect bullfight
06/26/03: Calling on London
06/20/03: Too upsetting for the evening news?
06/12/03: Rain(es)ing Clintoon myths
06/05/03: Hillary-ous is pathetic
05/22/03: End of the last great persecution of the 20th century?
05/15/03 :Grey turns to grim at Times
05/08/03: The only intellectual force in Western history to gain moral superiority by being wrong
05/01/03: Dinning with Tom Wolfe: More lessons in nusual aspects of American life, hitherto ignored
04/28/03: Ambuscade at scholarly frontier
04/21/03: Stars in search of a galaxy
04/10/03: Baghdad Bob and Tom Daschle
03/31/03: When the media itself becomes the story
03/20/03: Revealed! Estrada is a gifted linguist -- a Japanese-American fluent in Spanish
03/14/03: Genuinely in charge
03/10/03: Stalin and Saddam
03/05/03: They just cannot stomach a protracted alliance with the Bushies
02/25/03: Identity gridlock
02/18/03: People calling Dean a fruitcake are underestimating his political savvy
02/13/03: The new political establishment
01/30/03: The time is now
01/27/03: Witnessing self-love by people completely incapable of self-criticism
01/21/03: Of course our kiddies are depressed
01/13/03: Why is it that Official Washington still believes that a tax reduction means a revenue reduction?
01/02/03: Missing Moi
12/27/02: The grizzled and menacing-looking senator in Confederate drag is … a Dem
12/24/02: Uprooting Christianity in the Holy Land
12/20/02: Under fire, Lott showed an ignobleness that is embarrassing
11/26/02: Bartley's enemies have been routed
11/14/02: Clarence Thomas and the segregationist Mississippi sheriff
11/07/02: I muffed up
10/31/02: Is the American university turning its back on change, on progress?
10/24/02: So why aren't the Dems buoyant?
10/17/02: Mourning the loss of the "yellow-belly"
10/10/02: American politics at its most ignominious
10/03/02: A man above the law, a bully
09/26/02: Is Bob Greene a victim of an anti-Clinton backlash?
09/19/02: I knew Mafiosi and …
09/12/02: Chickens and poseurs
09/05/02: Sympathizing with the Europols
08/29/02: 9-11 did not change us forever
08/22/02: Public persons frivoling with serious matters
08/15/02: Beachcombing among the fat of the land
08/08/02: They pave the way for corruption, not personal responsibility
08/01/02: Believing the unbelievable
07/25/02: The congressional posse comitatus
07/18/02: Cosmopolitan Arab fashion
07/11/02: What the prez actually knows
07/04/02: The vindication of a truly original thinker
06/27/02: The perfect book for Hillary
06/20/02: To say that they were ordinary is not to slight them
06/13/02: Daschle must begin to act like an adult
06/06/02: Lack of "intelligence" --- and sheer stupidity
05/30/02: Revealing a carefully guarded media secret
05/23/02: In these times, thank Heaven for Clinton!
05/16/02: Fast Times at the Church of the Nativity
05/09/02: "Name the Prettiest Suicide Bomber"
05/02/02: Vindication for the Boy Scouts
04/25/02: A topic almost no other columnist will touch
04/18/02: 'Conventional Wisdom' --- and those who defy it
04/11/02: Let the Sun shine in
04/05/02: Hooded men of color in sheets
04/01/02: A McCain-Feingold Act for Hollywood
03/21/02: Yakkin' on Yates
03/15/02: No role for Paul Volcker in Enron: the movie
03/07/02: My membership in the Communist Party U.S.A.
02/27/02: This award is bestowed by 'contrarians'
02/21/02: Mike Tyson: Made for Washington?
02/14/02: Enron as underdog?
02/07/02: Freed from the presence of money -- hard or soft -- most politicians would be just as bad
01/31/02: Needed: Bush to make a preemptive strike against his enemies …. Ones who'd like to see him fail even during war
01/24/02: Hucksters will move on to make their next marks
01/17/02: Debonair prez should begin to do the High Life
01/10/02: Move over Twinkies --- "the acne medicine made him do it!"
01/03/02: Leaving the Nazis looking comparatively humane
12/27/01: A "self-made journalist"
12/20/01: Calamities and unanticipated benefits
12/13/01: America's grief ought not to give comfort to those who caused it
12/06/01: Leahy, the strict civil libertarian!? A short-term exploiter of the Constitution is more like it
11/29/01: Welcome to Afghan, Maryland?
11/26/01: So, why don't more folks hate us?
11/15/01: America's quagmire and other certainties
11/09/01: No longer the smug statists, the prodigal Keynesians?
11/01/01: The New Seriousness
10/25/01: Bright lights and the Taliban
10/18/01: Is bin-Laden propaganda from Western intelligence?
10/12/01: No yellow ribbons
10/05/01: Bubba's back --- again!
09/28/01: Exposing peacetime's frauds
09/21/01: So protected, we're vulnerable
09/14/01: At Barbara Olson's home
09/11/01: Duh! All conservatives are racists
08/31/01: Arafat's terrorists have created their own hell
08/24/01: Time for some political prophecy
08/16/01: They claim to be doing so much good
08/10/01: Visiting the source of the White House braintrust
08/03/01: Morality and reality
07/31/01: Blinded by success?
07/24/01: The latest Kennedy capitulation in Massachusetts
07/13/01: Talk about tawdry
07/06/01: Delighting in the Dictator
06/29/01: The G-dphobes
06/21/01: Fashionable Washington is sempiternally in a stew
06/15/01: The limits of hypocrisy
06/08/01: Flagging our general apathy
© 2001, Creators Syndicate