Jewish World Review August 29, 2002 / 21 Elul, 5762

Bob Tyrrell

Bob Greene
JWR's Pundits
World Editorial
Cartoon Showcase

Mallard Fillmore

Michael Barone
Mona Charen
Linda Chavez
Ann Coulter
Greg Crosby
Larry Elder
Don Feder
Suzanne Fields
Paul Greenberg
Bob Greene
Betsy Hart
Nat Hentoff
David Horowitz
Marianne Jennings
Michael Kelly
Mort Kondracke
Ch. Krauthammer
Lawrence Kudlow
Dr. Laura
John Leo
David Limbaugh
Michelle Malkin
Chris Matthews
Michael Medved
MUGGER
Kathleen Parker
Wes Pruden
Sam Schulman
Amity Shlaes
Tony Snow
Thomas Sowell
Cal Thomas
Jonathan S. Tobin
Ben Wattenberg
George Will
Bruce Williams
Walter Williams
Mort Zuckerman

Consumer Reports

9-11 did not change us forever


http://www.NewsAndOpinion.com | There is a habit of mind, among pundits and TV's talking heads, of apprising Americans of how they "feel" or what they "think" about this or that. Frankly, when I hear one of these mind readers making such a presumptuous asseveration, I reach for the remote and opt for silence. How about you? Do you feel an urge to rebel when, say, the marmoreal Dan Rather solemnizes, "Today, Americans as a people, are feeling [fill in the blank]"?

The other day, I heard the goggle-eyed Larry King intone that September 11 changed us Americans "forever." I wondered if his equivalent, speaking to a radio audience in 1941, ever said anything like that. I also wondered what precisely Larry meant.

It is unlikely that any event, no matter how momentous or tragic, can change the essential qualities of a people. Thomas Jefferson, the authors of the "Federalist Papers" and other wise American scribes, during the first decades of our history, occasionally referred to "the genius of the people." By this they meant the fundamental values and characteristics of the Americans of their time. They thought the "genius" unique to our shores and our experience. Every nation's people have a genius, and those who wrote our Constitution and early laws did not think that genius was a plastic or ephemeral thing. They would doubt Larry King's easy pronouncement that Americans are fundamentally different today from what we were anterior to September 11.

I know that among public figures it is common to claim that after the tragedy of September we as a people "will never be the same," or some variation thereof. I have tried to discover the origin of this cliché, and the best I can do is trace it back to a Washington Post story dated Sept. 28, 2001. The story quotes Attorney General John Ashcroft as he put down the telephone after receiving word of the attacks on the World Trade Center. To those seated around him he said, "Our world has changed forever." From there it is a short journey to Larry King's formulation that Americans have changed forever.

The sentiment is doubtless well-intentioned, but what does it mean? It means there is a new patriotism in the land, which is all to the good, but there has always been a love of country in the land. The problem has been that throughout the twentieth century it was chic to snicker at that patriotism. I have just finished reading an advanced copy of a biography of the critic and wit H.L. Mencken. He was famous for snickering at American patriotism, as the book "The Skeptic: A Life of H.L. Mencken," by Terry Teachout, makes clear. What is even clearer is that many significant literary figures of the first half of the century applauded his snipes at patriotism, and even more, his disparagement of America.

There was an energetic anti-Americanism then. It was relatively harmless until evil people exploited it for their own propaganda purposes, for instance, the Nazis, the Communists, and more recently, the Islamicists. Long before September 11 and the Islamicists' hate-America chants I tired of this anti-Americanism. When it comported with the anti-American propaganda of the KGB and its dupes it was no longer amusing, and those who continued to espouse it were either very stupid or nihilists. A laugh or two at some American excess is one thing, but to portray America as a malign civilization is just the opposite of the truth.

Today, America is the good country that it has always striven to be. Its faults should surprise no one, and its virtues -- given the dark side of human history -- are amazing. Inasmuch as America has changed since September, it is a reversion to certain qualities of the past. As I have said, there is a return to patriotism. There is also a return to citizenship, to the idea of the good citizen. That is even more beneficial than patriotism.

During the 1990s, when some politicians lied in office with impunity and we now know some accountants and corporate executives deceived the public, some of us called for a return to the study of civics, which is to say the study of the rights and responsibilities of the good citizen. The study of civics is not returning to the classrooms, busy as they are with sex education classes, anger management seminars, and other conscience-raising bilge. Yet an awareness of the responsibilities of citizenship seems to be spreading through the land. As American citizenship stresses freedom and responsibility, that seriousness about citizenship will only make for a freer America.

If that is the great change of which Larry speaks, I am for it; but it is not all that new.

Enjoy this writer's work? Why not sign-up for the daily JWR update. It's free. Just click here.


JWR contributor Bob Tyrrell is editor in chief of The American Spectator. Comment by clicking here.

08/22/02: Public persons frivoling with serious matters
08/15/02: Beachcombing among the fat of the land
08/08/02: They pave the way for corruption, not personal responsibility
08/01/02: Believing the unbelievable
07/25/02: The congressional posse comitatus
07/18/02: Cosmopolitan Arab fashion
07/11/02: What the prez actually knows
07/04/02: The vindication of a truly original thinker
06/27/02: The perfect book for Hillary
06/20/02: To say that they were ordinary is not to slight them
06/13/02: Daschle must begin to act like an adult
06/06/02: Lack of "intelligence" --- and sheer stupidity
05/30/02: Revealing a carefully guarded media secret
05/23/02: In these times, thank Heaven for Clinton!
05/16/02: Fast Times at the Church of the Nativity
05/09/02: "Name the Prettiest Suicide Bomber"
05/02/02: Vindication for the Boy Scouts
04/25/02: A topic almost no other columnist will touch
04/18/02: 'Conventional Wisdom' --- and those who defy it
04/11/02: Let the Sun shine in
04/05/02: Hooded men of color in sheets
04/01/02: A McCain-Feingold Act for Hollywood
03/21/02: Yakkin' on Yates
03/15/02: No role for Paul Volcker in Enron: the movie
03/07/02: My membership in the Communist Party U.S.A.
02/27/02: This award is bestowed by 'contrarians'
02/21/02: Mike Tyson: Made for Washington?
02/14/02: Enron as underdog?
02/07/02: Freed from the presence of money -- hard or soft -- most politicians would be just as bad
01/31/02: Needed: Bush to make a preemptive strike against his enemies …. Ones who'd like to see him fail even during war
01/24/02: Hucksters will move on to make their next marks
01/17/02: Debonair prez should begin to do the High Life
01/10/02: Move over Twinkies --- "the acne medicine made him do it!"
01/03/02: Leaving the Nazis looking comparatively humane
12/27/01: A "self-made journalist"
12/20/01: Calamities and unanticipated benefits
12/13/01: America's grief ought not to give comfort to those who caused it
12/06/01: Leahy, the strict civil libertarian!? A short-term exploiter of the Constitution is more like it
11/29/01: Welcome to Afghan, Maryland?
11/26/01: So, why don't more folks hate us?
11/15/01: America's quagmire and other certainties
11/09/01: No longer the smug statists, the prodigal Keynesians?
11/01/01: The New Seriousness
10/25/01: Bright lights and the Taliban
10/18/01: Is bin-Laden propaganda from Western intelligence?
10/12/01: No yellow ribbons
10/05/01: Bubba's back --- again!
09/28/01: Exposing peacetime's frauds
09/21/01: So protected, we're vulnerable
09/14/01: At Barbara Olson's home
09/11/01: Duh! All conservatives are racists
08/31/01: Arafat's terrorists have created their own hell
08/24/01: Time for some political prophecy
08/16/01: They claim to be doing so much good
08/10/01: Visiting the source of the White House braintrust
08/03/01: Morality and reality
07/31/01: Blinded by success?
07/24/01: The latest Kennedy capitulation in Massachusetts
07/13/01: Talk about tawdry
07/06/01: Delighting in the Dictator
06/29/01: The Godphobes
06/21/01: Fashionable Washington is sempiternally in a stew
06/15/01: The limits of hypocrisy
06/08/01: Flagging our general apathy

© 2001, Creators Syndicate