Here’s the truth: I’m a baker who is known for her pies, and I do not like pumpkin pie. The filling is either rubbery or resembles mushy baby food. And beneath the custard, the crust is often soggy - or even completely underbaked. Sure, the whipped cream helps the situation, but it shouldn’t hold all responsibility for saving an otherwise inedible slice.
In my opinion, a good pie should check off a few boxes: a nice combination of contrasting textures, a not-too-sweet balance of flavors between the filling and crust, and easy sliceability. Because I also deeply love Thanksgiving and the traditional recipes associated with the holiday, I’ve spent a lot of time finding the sweet spot - a pie recipe that even I, a certified pumpkin-pie hater, can love.
I have nothing against the flavors of pumpkin itself, or the much-beloved pumpkin spice, and I happily use both in all manner of pastries and bakes. Instead of trying to “fix” what I don’t love about classic pumpkin pie, I’m proposing a pumpkin-y pivot to a different but much-cherished category: the cream pie. While this family of pies can encompass many styles, one of my favorites is filled with creamy, thick pudding made on the stovetop. I have a whole section in my newest cookbook, “Bake Anything,” devoted to this style of pie, because they are easy to make, and even easier to love.
One reason for their popularity is because they are piled high with whipped cream (yum). In addition to being delicious, this also makes them super impressive-looking. Yet they’re much easier to make than they may appear . Best of all, because they need to be chilled , they are make-ahead-friendly, too.
Here’s another plus: This Pumpkin Cream Pie requires minimal total bake time, a huge bonus for holiday time when the oven is already packed and working in shifts. The only element that requires baking is the crumb crust, which is simple and straightforward. The filling ingredients are whisked together and slowly heated on the stovetop until properly thickened.
The key is cooking the pudding sufficiently to ensure that it achieves the perfect sliceable texture after chilling, a task that’s not difficult but requires a little faith and some precise timing. What you’re ultimately looking for are bubbles - but not tiny little bubbles around the outer edges of the pot. Instead, you want big, fat bubbles breaking the surface of the thickened pudding from the center of the pot. Sometimes, you have to stop stirring for a moment to clearly see these bubbles - but it’s not quite finished when you first see them. Once you’ve spotted that first big, fat bubble, keep stirring until you can see more of them breaking the surface even when stirring. This is a good indication that the custard has heated all the way through and the cornstarch is sufficiently activated.
The hot pudding is then strained into the cooled crust, and its surface is covered with plastic wrap to prevent a skin from forming as it cools.
After several hours in the fridge, the pie is ready to be served - but it can be held for 24 hours, and even up to 2 days, if it helps your holiday prep plans.
A generous heap of whipped cream is the perfect finishing touch. (Bonus: It’s naturally stabilized thanks to the addition of cream cheese, so it won’t weep even with extended fridge time.) Pile it on and give it swirly swoops using the back of a spoon for a photo-worthy effect. Or if you’re feeling really fancy, try piping on swirls or dollops with a pastry bag and a large star tip.
The result is a pie even a pumpkin-pie skeptic like me will adore. Creamy, spiced filling, with a crisp, buttery crumb crust. It’s everything I love in a good pie: the flavors, the textures, the not-too-sweet but incredibly satisfying taste.
And the sliceability? Well, I’ve saved the best for last! Cold-set pies like this are some of the easiest to achieve a clean slice with, because they are served chilled. So grab the camera, because you might want to capture a snapshot of your impressive, photogenic, cream-topped dessert. Even if you’re not the anointed family baker, this pie is guaranteed to impress the crowd this holiday season.
Pumpkin Cream Pie
Servings: 8
Active Time: 1 hour 15 minutes; Total Time: 6 hours 15 minutes
Storage: The pie is best the day it is made, but leftovers can be wrapped and refrigerated for up to 2 days.
Make Ahead: The baked crust can be wrapped tightly and refrigerated for up to 2 days or frozen for up to 3 months. If freezing, defrost overnight in the refrigerator before proceeding with the recipe. The filled pie, minus the whipped cream, needs to be refrigerated for at least 4 hours and up to 24 hours before serving. The whipped cream can be prepared and refrigerated in an airtight container for up to 48 hours.
This pumpkin pie delivers all the familiar flavors of tradition, but with a silky, luscious pudding that sets up in the crust, no additional baking required. As long as you cook it enough, the pudding will firm up to render clean slices, so be sure to let the mixture come to a full boil and cook it for a few minutes once it does, until it registers around 180 to 185 degrees on an instant-read thermometer. Avoid the temptation to pull it off the heat too soon, as the pudding will be too soft to slice through cleanly once the pie is cooled. A crown of tangy whipped cream is stabilized by a little cream cheese, to ensure the topping doesn’t weep or sag.
Ingredients:
For the crust
• 7 1/2 ounces (212 grams) gingersnaps
• 1/4 cup (50 grams) granulated sugar
• 1/2 teaspoon fine salt
• 6 tablespoons (85 grams) unsalted butter, melted, plus more as needed For the pudding
• 3/4 cup (160 grams) packed dark brown sugar
• Scant 1/3 cup (37 grams) cornstarch
• 1/2 teaspoon fine salt
• 1 (15-ounce/425-gram) can pumpkin puree
• 1 1/2 cups (345 grams) whole milk
• 1/2 cup (118 grams) heavy cream
• 4 large egg yolks (85 grams total)
• 2 teaspoons pumpkin spice
• 1 tablespoon unsalted butter
• 2 teaspoons vanilla extract or vanilla bean paste
For the whipped cream
• 4 ounces (113 grams) cream cheese, softened
• 1/4 cup (50 grams) granulated sugar
• 1 cup (235 grams) cold heavy cream
• 1 teaspoon vanilla extract or vanilla bean paste (optional) STEPS:
1: Make the crust: Position a rack in the middle of the oven and preheat to 350 degrees. Have ready a 9-inch (23-centimeter) pie dish.
2: To the bowl of a food processor, add the gingersnaps and pulse until finely ground. Add the granulated sugar and salt, and pulse to incorporate.
3: Transfer the mixture to a medium bowl and add the melted butter. Use a flexible spatula to mix and evenly distribute the butter, until the mixture has the texture of wet sand. Squeeze a portion of the mixture in your hand - it should hold together. If it doesn’t, add additional melted butter, 1 tablespoon (14 grams) at a time, until it does. You should have about 1 3/4 cups.
4: Lightly grease the pie dish with butter. Transfer the gingersnap mixture to the pie dish and use a 2-inch (5-centimeter) glass to press the crumbs into the bottom and sides of the dish to about 1/4-inch (6-millimeter) thickness. Set the pie dish on a large sheet pan and place in the oven.
5: Bake for 12 to 15 minutes, or until the crust smells toasty and is lightly browned. Transfer to a wire rack and let cool completely before filling.
6: Make the pudding: In a small bowl, whisk together the brown sugar, cornstarch and salt until well combined.
7: In a medium (4-quart/4-liter) saucepan, whisk together the pumpkin puree, milk, cream, egg yolks and pumpkin spice until well combined. Whisk in the brown sugar mixture until well combined.
8: Set the saucepan over medium heat, and use a whisk to gently and constantly stir the mixture while it heats. As it continues to thicken, switch to a flexible spatula and continue stirring constantly, paying special attention to the bottom and corners of the pot to keep the mixture in motion and ensure that the pudding isn’t thickening more in those places. Continue cooking, scraping the bottom and sides constantly, until the mixture comes to a “first boil” - small bubbles may appear around the edge of the pot before this happens - and a large bubble, or a few, appears in the center of the pot, 7 to 10 minutes. Continue cooking the mixture, stirring constantly, until you see large, viscous bubbles popping lazily across the entire surface of the pudding. Stop stirring for a few seconds to verify the boil. (If you see a bubble, stir, and if it takes a bit before another bubble appears, the mixture hasn’t come to the proper temperature, and the cornstarch won’t be fully activated, which means the pudding will be loose and not set.) Once the mixture is boiling throughout, continue cooking, stirring constantly, until it thickens considerably and registers around 180 to 185 degrees on an instant-read thermometer, 2 to 3 minutes. The mixture will hiss and sputter as you stir it.
9: Remove from the heat, and stir in the butter and vanilla until fully melted and incorporated. Strain the pudding through a large fine-mesh sieve into a medium bowl, pressing on it with a flexible spatula to push the mixture through. The mixture will be thick, so don’t be afraid to really push it through the strainer. You should have about 4 cups (1 liter). Transfer the pudding to the cooled crust and use a flexible or offset spatula to smooth the top. Cover the surface of the pudding directly with plastic or beeswax wrap, and refrigerate until completely chilled and set, at least 4 hours and up to 24 hours.
10: Make the whipped cream and finish the pie: At least 15 minutes before you’re ready to serve, chill the bowl of a stand mixer (or a large bowl) and the whisk attachment(s). When ready to serve, in the chilled bowl of a stand mixer fitted with the whisk attachment, or in a large bowl if using a hand mixer, beat the cream cheese and granulated sugar on medium speed until light and fluffy, 2 to 3 minutes. Thoroughly scrape the sides and bottom of the bowl.
11: Reduce the speed to medium-low and add the cream in a slow, steady stream until fully incorporated. Continue mixing for 1 minute, then very thoroughly scrape the sides and bottom of the bowl to ensure no unmixed bits of cream cheese remain. Add the vanilla, if using, increase the mixer speed to medium and continue to beat until the mixture holds stiff peaks, about 3 minutes. You should have about 2 cups (480 milliliters).
12: Remove the wrap from the surface of the filling and spoon the whipped cream on top, spreading it in an even layer or piling it higher in the center for a classic pie look. You can also pipe it onto the pie for a fancier effect, covering the pie fully or just the outer edges. Slice the pie and serve immediately.
Substitutions: Whole milk >> reduced-fat milk.
Gingersnaps >> graham crackers.
Out of pumpkin pie spice? >> Make your own (see related recipes).
Canned pumpkin puree >> canned sweet potato puree.
Dark brown sugar >> light brown sugar, though the flavor will be slightly less rich.
(COMMENT, BELOW)

Contact The Editor
Articles By This Author