Wednesday

November 18th, 2026

Inside Politics

Senate majority leader fight intensifies as Schumer, Van Hollen dig in

Theodoric Meyer

By Theodoric Meyer The Washington Post

Published Nov. 18, 2026

  Senate majority leader fight intensifies as Schumer, Van Hollen dig in

SIGN UP FOR THE DAILY JWR UPDATE. IT'S FREE. (AND NO SPAM!) Just click here.

The race for Senate majority leader is intensifying as Sen. Chris Van Hollen (D-Maryland) challenges Sen. Chuck Schumer (D-New York), who has led Senate Democrats for the past decade, with both lawmakers back in Washington and lobbying their colleagues.

Schumer and Van Hollen found themselves in the same room on Tuesday as Democrats met for their weekly lunch in the Capitol, the first time since Van Hollen announced his bid last week.

More than a dozen current and newly elected Democratic senators have committed to backing Schumer, who said Tuesday that he is confident he has enough votes to defeat Van Hollen.

Four Democrats have publicly backed Van Hollen, who has said nearly a dozen more support him privately. Most Senate Democrats have not revealed whom they plan to support - which Van Hollen argues gives him an opening to win over his colleagues.

The vote is scheduled to take place Dec. 1 by secret ballot, making it a challenge for Van Hollen or Schumer to be certain how many votes they command. Sen. Dick Durbin (Illinois), who is retiring after two decades as the No. 2 Senate Democrat, said senators do not always vote the way they say they will.

"Having stood for election several times when it was contested within the caucus, that happens regularly," he told reporters.

Stories about the perils of the secret ballot in leadership races are common. When Sen. Lamar Alexander (R-Tennessee) lost the race for Senate minority whip to Sen. Trent Lott (R-Mississippi) in 2006, he told colleagues, "I will be writing 27 thank-you notes for 24 votes," according to his recent memoir, "The Education of a Senator."

Van Hollen is running on a message of change after Democrats recaptured the Senate in the midterm elections. Two of his supporters - Abdul El-Sayed (D-Michigan) and Peggy Flanagan (D-Minnesota) - just won their first terms, and Van Hollen has pledged to lift up the voices of the newest Democratic senators.

"I really am worried that we might blow what could be a huge opportunity to deliver for the American people," Van Hollen told reporters.

Other Democrats argue it does not make sense to oust Schumer after he helped Democrats defy the odds to retake the Senate, winning the party's largest majority since the Obama administration.

"The Democrats are the only party in the country, in the world, where you can flip double the number of seats anybody, even the biggest optimist, thought was possible - and then there's a revolt [against] the person who helped lead that," Sen. John Hickenlooper (D-Colorado) told reporters.

Still, Hickenlooper has not committed to supporting Schumer or Van Hollen, saying he wants to hear them out.

Schumer or Van Hollen will need to secure at least 28 votes to win if every eligible member in the Democratic caucus is voting.

Democrats next year are set to hold 56 Senate seats, including those held by independent Sens. Bernie Sanders (Vermont) and Angus King (Maine), if former Democratic congresswoman Mary Peltola wins a Senate seat in Alaska. Peltola is leading Republican Sen. Dan Sullivan in a race that remains uncalled.

Newly elected Democratic senators are allowed to vote, while outgoing senators are not. Neither Sen. Amy Klobuchar (D-Minnesota), who is leaving the Senate after she was elected governor, nor her successor can vote because she will not appoint one until she becomes governor in January.

Many of the senators who have not endorsed in the race have served alongside Schumer and Van Hollen for years - or in Schumer's case, even decades. Schumer, 75, was first elected to the Senate in 1998. Van Hollen, 67, won his seat in 2016. Schumer has not said whether he plans to run for a sixth term in 2028.

Sen. Cory Booker (D-New Jersey), who has not endorsed in the race, described the leadership fight as "a family conversation." Sen. Peter Welch (D-Vermont), who also has not said which contender he is supporting, chose a different metaphor.

"Did you ever run for class president?" Welch quipped.

The race is the first contested election for Democratic Senate leader since 1994, when Tom Daschle (South Dakota) beat Chris Dodd (Connecticut) by one vote. No sitting Democratic Senate leader has faced a challenge since 1984, when Lawton Chiles (Florida) tried and failed to oust Robert Byrd (West Virginia) as minority leader, according to the Senate Historical Office.

A handful of Democrats have said they will not vote for Schumer but have not committed publicly to supporting Van Hollen. One of them, Sen.-elect Adam Hamilton (D-Kansas), said on NBC News's "Meet the Press" after the election that he is "looking for is a leader who can lead from the center, somebody who can bring Republicans and Democrats together."

Van Hollen is an outspoken progressive who is challenging Schumer with the support of Sanders, though he has said his decision to challenge Schumer is not rooted in ideology.

Sen.-elect Annie Andrews (D-South Carolina), who has not said whom she plans to support for leader, said she expressed concern to her new colleagues last week that the leadership fight could distract the party from pursuing its agenda.

"I used a medical analogy," Andrews, a pediatrician, told reporters Tuesday. "It's like if there was a patient bleeding out in the trauma bay and the cardiothoracic surgeon and trauma surgeon were standing outside the trauma bay arguing about who was going to take the lead - when really what we need is someone just to stop the bleeding."

Other Democrats said they viewed the leadership fight as healthy, even if it takes time. Senate Democrats changed their rules to allow more time for debate after reelecting Harry M. Reid (Nevada) as their leader in 2014 the week after Democrats lost the Senate majority. Some Senate Democrats have suggested changing those rules to speed things up this year, but the party has made no moves to do so.

Sen. Tim Kaine (D-Virginia) said he was not concerned that the leadership battle would distract the party from pushing forward with its agenda.

"We're Democrats," Kaine said. "We believe in democracy. It's a healthy process."

(COMMENT, BELOW)

Previously:
• After losing Congress, will Republicans finally manage to pass their agenda?
• The seven races that will decide control of the Senate
• As Dem candidates outraise Republicans, GOP megadonors rush to fill the gap
• Bipartisan backlash against a technology that has been abused by law enforcement
• Move to portray Cruz as a sell-out RINO?
• Fetterman appears by video at GOP convention and pledges he'll work with Trump
• Seeking to flip Senate, Dems are running ads to criticize their own
• Backlash in Michigan complicates Dems' road to retaking the Senate
• Senate votes to take up Trump's voting bill to 'guarantee the midterms'

Columnists

Toons