Tuesday

May 21st, 2024

Life

Do you like the tradwife trend?

Danny Tyree

By Danny Tyree

Published March 22, 2023

Do you like the tradwife trend?
"No wife of mine will ever have to work outside the home if she doesn't want to."

I uttered that cocky, naïve declaration five years before meeting my wife and 11 years before getting married.

Cold, hard reality forced us both to bring in paychecks and juggle household duties. (Well, we weren't always home. Sometimes we spied on the rich folks as they enjoyed the decadence of ramen noodles and milk crate furniture.)

Today many couples are crunching the numbers and finding ways to survive with a single breadwinner and the "tradwife" philosophy.

In case you haven't seen it trending on social media, tradwives ("traditional wives") are a subculture of housewives who believe in clear gender roles, the importance of homemaking and admiration (if not subservience) for their husbands.

It's true: not everyone is geared to handle the competitiveness of a two-income family. "Let me unload on you about what a jerk my boss and all the other commuters were today!!" "No, let me unload on you about what a jerk my boss and all the other commuters were today!!!" "Hey, let's both unload on the cop who is at the door with the president of the homeowners' association…"

I suspect lots of men with a decent income are intrigued by the idea of a tradwife, but many women either pity tradwives or feel threatened. ("Look out! She's got a rug beater and she knows how to use it!")

Tradwives take flak from women who have no desire for a husband or children. They also face denigration by women who feel driven to maintain both a high-powered career and a family.

As for the latter, I realize many women still cling to the idea of "having it all," but the world captured in the old Enjoli perfume commercial no longer exists (if it ever did). No, now the jingle would be "I can bring home the plant-based bacon…fry it up in a pan on a non-gas stove…and never let you forget that you're a man, unless that's something you'd like to forget. Not that there's anything wrong with that."

SIGN UP FOR THE DAILY JWR UPDATE. IT'S FREE. Just click here.

There's nothing wrong with trying the tradwife lifestyle, as long as a woman enters into it with both eyes wide open. Exception: if the wife gushes, "John says it's okay to enter into it with both eyes wide open as long as I remove any skanky eyeshadow from my eyelids, fetch his pipe and slippers and cluck like a chicken," she needs to grab the two-point-five children and skedaddle.

A lot of tradwives on social media proudly display clothing and decorations reminiscent of a 1950s issue of "Ladies' Home Journal." Nothing wrong with the old-timey theme unless it's carried to extremes and provokes the sort of anxiety the tradwife lifestyle is supposed to eliminate. ("What if William brings Nikita Khrushchev to dinner? Does pot roast go with borscht? Will I be able to get the scuff marks out if he pounds his shoe on the dining room table?")

If a woman feels fulfilled homeschooling her children, keeping the windows spotless, raising a garden and cooking from scratch, more power to her. Just as long as she doesn't rely too heavily on heirloom cookbooks such as "The Lard Is My Shepherd" or "You Call That A Salt Shaker? This Is A Salt Shaker!"

Else, she might abruptly become a tradwidow movement influencer.

(COMMENT, BELOW)

Controversial author Harlan Ellison once described the work of Mr. Tyree as "wonkily extrapolative" and said his mind "works like a demented cuckoo clock." Tyree generated a particular buzz on the Internet with his column spoofing real-life Christian nudist camps. A lifelong small-town southerner, he graduated from Middle Tennessee State University in 1982 with a bachelor's degree in Mass Communications.

Previously:
Have you ever taken your business elsewhere?
Journalism: Can't live with it, can't live without it
Shall we sing the praises of public restrooms?
Given up on your 2023 reading list yet?
Cold enough for you?
M*A*S*H, MAUDE and KUNG FU all turn 50
Does your body hate you?
Do Gallup poll respondents have a prayer?
Was your grandfather a character?
Is a platonic life partnership right for you?
Do you hate intersections too?
The 'Rural Purge' of 1971
Do morning people deserve to live?
What will Presidents' Day be like in 50 years?
Are you and your middle name on speaking terms?
Have you ever met a stranger?
Do you dare take the goodness challenge??
Commercial radio turns 100: what are your favorite memories?
What shall we say about 50 years of home ownership?
Do you dread opening your car trunk?
So this is John Lennon's 80th birthday (And what have you done?)
Come on, get happy: the Partridge Family at 50
Come on, get happy: the Partridge Family at 50
Who can turn the world on with her anniversary?
Inspirational quotes: Are you for them or against them?
Ray Bradbury: Something centenary this way comes
'Ban Bossy': Unintended Consequences
Almost Here: A Translator For Dogs!
Will Eggs Become Obsolete?
Doctor Who: A Fiftieth Anniversary Primer
The Martians Were Coming, The Martians Were Coming
Are Pigs Smarter Than Dogs? And Should We Care?
America, Let's Be #1 At Corruption
Free College Tuition? Read The Fine Print
Independence Day: Life, Liberty and the Pursuit of Typos
Let's Have More Wrist Slap Punishments
Father's Day: Can It Survive?

Columnists

Toons