Clicking on banner ads enables JWR to constantly improve
Jewish World Review August 11, 2003 / 13 Menachem-Av, 5763

Jonathan Turley

Turley
JWR's Pundits
World Editorial
Cartoon Showcase

Mallard Fillmore

Michael Barone
Mona Charen
Linda Chavez
Ann Coulter
Greg Crosby
Larry Elder
Don Feder
Suzanne Fields
James Glassman
Paul Greenberg
Bob Greene
Betsy Hart
Nat Hentoff
David Horowitz
Marianne Jennings
Michael Kelly
Mort Kondracke
Ch. Krauthammer
Lawrence Kudlow
Dr. Laura
John Leo
Michelle Malkin
Jackie Mason
Chris Matthews
Michael Medved
MUGGER
Kathleen Parker
Wes Pruden
Sam Schulman
Amity Shlaes
Roger Simon
Tony Snow
Thomas Sowell
Cal Thomas
Jonathan S. Tobin
Ben Wattenberg
George Will
Bruce Williams
Walter Williams
Mort Zuckerman

Consumer Reports


Don't let jobs grow on family trees


http://www.NewsAndOpinion.com | When he became governor of Alaska, Frank Murkowski had to decide who should finish the two years remaining on his U.S. Senate term. After a supposedly exhaustive search, Murkowski appointed his daughter, Lisa Murkowski.

Although the first U.S. senator appointed by a father, Lisa Murkowski is hardly unique among the children and spouses of politicians. For example, Vice President Cheney's daughter, Elizabeth Cheney, and his son-in-law, Philip Perry, were appointed by President Bush to high-level positions: deputy assistant secretary of State and chief counsel for the Office of Management and Budget, respectively.

Nepotism is on the rise, both in Washington and across the nation. After decades of decreases in nepotism under good government laws, there has not just been a resurgence in the practice, but also a new boldness, if not defiance, among government officials using their offices to benefit their family members.

These officials can find support in a new book by Adam Bellow, "In Praise of Nepotism." Defending preferential treatment based on family connections, he argues that society gains from family dynasties, which tend to stabilize government. He also believes that hiring famous names is akin to buying a quality trademark.

Nepotism, however, is one of the oldest forms of corruption -- and often the first sign of eroding ethics and a lack of public involvement in government. For this reason, it is alarming to see it on the rise in Hollywood, sports, business, pop music and government, as Bellow confirms. Indeed, in the past couple of years, members of the Bush administration and Congress have openly used their offices to lobby for appointments of children, siblings and parents to judgeships and government jobs.

Donate to JWR

Some of these relatives were criticized as less qualified than other applicants or entirely unqualified, yet still got the positions. The late senator Strom Thurmond, R-S.C., secured confirmation of his son as a U.S. attorney, despite the fact that the then-28-year-old had prosecuted only seven cases on his own in his two years as an assistant state attorney. Likewise, Sen. Jim Bunning, R-Ky., lobbied for a federal judgeship for his 35-year-old son, despite his "unqualified" American Bar Association rating.

Other relatives have found more lucrative jobs as lobbyists. The Los Angeles Times recently reported that at least 28 members of Congress have close relatives working as Washington lobbyists, some without experience. GOP Sen. Trent Lott's son, Chet, managed pizza restaurants and played polo before becoming a telecommunications lobbyist. The family of Senate minority leader Tom Daschle, D-S.D., includes his wife, Linda, an aviation lobbyist; his daughter-in-law, Jill, a lobbyist for companies such as Aetna and Blue Cross; and his son, Nathan, a former labor union lobbyist.

Nepotism has always plagued our system to some degree. John F. Kennedy appointed his brother as attorney general, and Bill Clinton made his wife the head of a powerful federal commission on health care. Former House speaker Tom Foley, D-Wash., made his wife, Heather, his chief of staff. Bellow points to such cases as recent evidence of a practice that has existed since the earliest forms of government. Of course, inbreeding also has a long history, but it's hardly a model for good family planning.

The appointment of family members of powerful figures is the modern equivalent of ancient medieval marriages between families of different kingdoms. Such unions give powerful members of Congress and the judiciary vested interests in an administration's success. The Bush administration seems especially eager to cross-pollinate its ranks with the children and spouses of politicians and judges. Elaine Chao, the wife of Sen. Mitch McConnell, R-Ky., is Labor secretary. Associate Justice Antonin Scalia's son, Eugene, was appointed by Bush as the top Labor Department lawyer. Chief Justice William Rehnquist's daughter, Janet, was appointed Health and Human Services' inspector general until she left in a scandal.

Bellow argues that the progeny of leaders are likely to be more talented and dedicated -- an assumption of genetic superiority that borders on governmental eugenics. History hardly supports such a sweeping assumption. For every Robert Kennedy, one can point to a Billy Carter or Roger Clinton.

Moreover, while a child of a powerful leader may have (as Bellow suggests) a special interest in succeeding, the child's family name also makes it more difficult to criticize or remove him when he proves incompetent. For example, the conduct of Rehnquist's daughter created a lot of controversy during her brief tenure as inspector general. But it took a federal investigation and confidential leaks to the media to finally dislodge her. No high-level Bush administration official wanted to hand a pink slip to the child of the chief justice on a court divided 5-4 on many important issues.

In Praise of Nepotism cultivates the myth of elite bloodlines. While Bellow insists that merit is an important factor in hiring, he toys with a practice that has been the scourge of good government. Unless citizens demand new rules against this ancient form of corruption, the natural impulses of procreation and politics will guarantee a new golden age of nepotism.

Every weekday JewishWorldReview.com publishes what many in Washington and in the media consider "must reading." Sign up for the daily JWR update. It's free. Just click here.



JWR contributor Jonathan Turley is a professor at the George Washington University Law School. Comment by clicking here.

06/26/03: A Ruling That Only Goldilocks Could Love; We still don't know how much weight to give race in college admissions
06/24/03: 'Educating' Congress at the hands of lobbyists
06/12/03: Crooked arm of the law
06/10/03: Defense on lay-away
05/23/03: Innocence doesn't pay, either
05/15/03: A see-no-evil parole system
05/08/03: An American Gulag?
05/01/03: CUNY Law gives grads a cynical parting gift
04/22/03: Congress Must Send Spammers a Message
04/16/03: End Apartheid in the State Prisons
04/07/03: NBC's sacking of Peter Arnett over a critical analysis plays well in Baghdad
03/07/03: Rights on the Rack: Alleged torture in terror war imperils U.S. standards of humanity
02/25/03: How democracy could clear our snowy streets
02/11/03: Sanity and Justice Slipping Away
01/28/03: Quit horsing around, senator
01/14/03: Public Payroll: a Family Affair; Nepotism in Washington poses a threat to institutional integrity
01/09/03: DARPA and democracy
12/24/02: The 13th juror
12/19/02: Back to the admissions morass
12/10/02: Pro-Choice at Expense of Free Speech; NOW case against abortion protester may backfire
12/02/02: A cruel bait and switch for vets
11/15/02: Junk justice
11/07/02: OUR second-class soldiers
10/30/02: 'Quirin' revisited: The dark history of a military tribunal
10/22/02: Un-American Arrests: Mass detainments of the innocent may be the ultimate form of crowd control, but the tactic is unconstitutional
10/16/02: Reverse pawn shops? Broke state officials across the country have been looking for businesses to buy their assets at a fraction of their worth to pay for budget shortfalls
10/08/02: A legal tattoo hullabaloo
10/02/02: Gagged justice sets dangerous precedent
09/25/02: The Great Salmon Rose Caper
09/17/02: Reparations: A Scam Cloaked in Racial Pain
09/12/02: This country's hidden strength
09/04/02: 1st Amendment protects even the ugliest among us
08/28/02: A secret court goes public
08/20/02: I defended Ashcroft during his nomination; he's become a constitutional menace
08/07/02: San Francisco embracing states-rights
07/31/02: Who needs Jenny Craig when you can have Johnnie Cochran?
07/22/02: The meaning of justice and the madness of Zacarias Moussauoi
07/16/02: The President vs. the Presidency
07/08/02: How one woman's whims dictates the rights of millions
07/02/02: Just say 'no' to extracurricular activities
06/24/02: Missing Ted Bundy
06/14/02: DESTROYING A FAMILY TO SAVE IT
06/10/02: A comedy of eros06/14/02: 05/31/02: Beyond the 'reformed FBI' hype
05/23/02: Do we really need a Federal Marriage Amendment?
05/19/02: No "battlefield detainee" should leave home without a U.S. birth certificate
05/10/02: The perfect constitutional storm
04/26/02: 'Slave of Allah' wounds justice
04/12/02: The importance of being nameless
04/05/02: The adjusted value of justice
03/18/02: How Clinton got off: A law professor's take
03/11/02: Profiling and the terrorist lottery
03/05/02: Yes, Sharpton, there was a failure of justice
02/28/02: The Lay of the land
02/14/02: Living in constitutional denial
02/05/02: Legal Lesson for Afghanistan: War's Not a Slip-and-Fall Case
01/25/02: Sever "Jihad Johnny"'s ties to his homeland
01/21/02: "Out of sight, out of mind," but they're still prisoners
01/14/02: Your papers, please!
01/07/02: Prescription for disaster
12/18/01: Madison and the Mujahedeen
12/07/01: In the U.S., espionage crime is easy to understand but difficult to prove
11/19/01: What type of 'creature' would defend bin Laden?
11/19/01: Could bin Laden be acquitted in a trial?
10/28/01: The ultimate sign of the different times in which we are living
10/25/01: Al-Qaida produces killers, not thinkers
09/28/01: The Boxer rebellion and the war against terrorism
08/31/01: Bring back the silent Condit
08/27/01: Working out the body politic

© 2002, Jonathan Turley