Thursday

May 2nd, 2024

Insight

How Queen Esther became American

Jeff Jacoby

By Jeff Jacoby

Published March 6, 2023

This week Jews will celebrate the festival of Purim. It is one of the most joyous and entertaining holidays in the Jewish calendar. It lasts for only a day, but it is packed with beloved rituals and traditions — dressing up in costumes, exchanging treats with friends, giving gifts to the poor, drinking more than usual , and generally making merry. The most important ritual of all is the public reading of the Book of Esther, arguably the most popular, and certainly the most dramatic, narrative in the entire Hebrew Bible.

In 10 fast-paced chapters, the Book of Esther recounts an attempted genocide of the Jews in ancient Persia. The Persian emperor Ahasuerus (known better to historians as Xerxes I ) allows himself to be persuaded by Haman, an influential royal adviser, that the Jews are a disloyal and disobedient minority who ought to be eradicated.

The emperor signs an edict authorizing Haman and his followers "to destroy, to kill, and to annihilate all the Jews, both young and old, women and children, in one day."

But the plot is foiled thanks to court intrigues involving Mordechai, the leader of the Jewish community in the imperial city of Shushan, and the audacity of Esther, the young Jewish heroine who wins a beauty contest and becomes Ahasuerus's queen.

In the end, Haman and his followers are killed, and Mordechai is named to replace him as the king's chief adviser.

The Book of Esther is easy to read and understand; it has memorable characters and a plot line filled with high tension and comic relief. But beneath the surface are profound complexities and puzzles — it makes no mention of G od, for example — and over the millennia, Jewish sages and scholars have mined vital insights from its text. From the nature of antisemitism to the fate of Jews in exile to the dangers of bad political leadership, there are depths of meaning to be found in the Book of Esther.

But it isn't only Jews for whom this biblical tale has resonated over time. It has inspired countless Americans as well, and in far more ways than I had realized before reading Esther in America, an eclectic collection of short, informed, and compelling essays edited by Stuart Halpern, a scholar and administrator at Yeshiva University. From New England Puritans in the 17th century to Hollywood's moviemakers in the 20th, the Book of Esther has repeatedly turned up in American rhetoric, art, and politics.

( Buy "Esther in America" In hardcover at a discount! by clicking here or order in KINDLE edition at a (72% discount by clicking here. Sales help fund JWR.)


The great American abolitionist and civil rights activist Sojourner Truth, who was born into slavery in 1797, never learned to read or write. But she knew the biblical story of Esther and invoked it in a powerful speech in September 1853, when she addressed the Women's Rights Convention in New York City.

The meeting had been invaded by male hecklers and protesters hostile to women's equality. They loudly booed and hissed when Truth took the floor. Undaunted, she faced down the rabble . She told them she would speak whether they wanted her to or not. After all, hadn't Queen Esther done just that in ancient Persia, when she summoned the courage to enter the royal court without permission — a breach of etiquette so severe that she could have been killed on the spot?

"I was a-thinking, when I see women contending for their rights, I was a-thinking what a difference there is now, and what there was in old times," said Truth.

There was a king in the Scriptures — and then it was the kings of the earth would kill a woman if she come into their presence — but Queen Esther come forth, for she was oppressed, and felt there was a great wrong, and she said I will die or I will bring my complaint before the king. Should the king of the United States be greater, or more crueler, or more harder?

But the king, he raised up his scepter and said: "Thy request shall be granted unto thee — to the half of my kingdom will I grant it to thee!" Then he said he would hang Haman on the gallows he had made up high. But that is not what women come forward to contend. The women want their rights as Esther [did]. She wanted only to explain their rights. And he was so liberal that he said, "the half of my kingdom shall be granted to thee," and did not wait for her to ask, he was so liberal with her.

Now, women do not ask half of a kingdom, but their rights, and they don't get them. When she come to demand them, don't you hear how sons hiss their mothers like snakes, because they ask for their rights? Can they ask for anything less? The king ordered Haman to be hung on the gallows which he prepared to hang others; but I do not want any man to be killed, but I am sorry to see them so short-minded. But we'll have our rights; see if we don't. And you can't stop us from them; see if you can. You may hiss as much as you like, but it is coming.

Halpern writes that Truth's citation of the ancient Jewish heroine "as a prism through which to view her fight for equal rights was no anomaly. Throughout history, Americans have turned to the Scroll of Esther, the megilla, as they navigated their liberties, morals, passions, and politics." Time and again, Americans, Jewish and non-Jewish alike, have found way to reinterpret a narrative "whose themes — freedom, power, fraught sexual dynamics, ethnicity, and peoplehood — continue to define American identity to this day."

In the years preceding the Revolutionary War, as American colonists struggled to accommodate their loyalty to the British crown with the outrages being imposed upon them by His Majesty's Government, the Book of Esther provided a metaphorical opening to denounce the king's policies without speaking ill of George III himself. They did so, as historian Eran Shalev notes in an eye-opening essay ("Haman in the American Revolution"), by blaming those policies on royal advisers who in their wickedness had misled the king.

SIGN UP FOR THE DAILY JWR UPDATE. IT'S FREE. Just click here.

In November 1766, for example, the Boston Gazette fumed that the much hated Stamp Act — the brainchild of Prime Minister George Grenville — could only have been the work of someone who was "as great an Enemy . . . as was wicked Haman to the Jews." Again and again the argument was made. In September 1774, just months before the outbreak of hostilities at Concord and Lexington, the New York Journal continued to give the king the benefit of the doubt. He was not the villain, the paper argued; it was the scheming, Haman-like prime minister who must have "led his sovereign to view many of his innocent subjects as rebels."

In another essay, Meir Y. Soloveichik tells of a delegation of pastors who met with President Lincoln in the White House in the fall of 1862. The clergymen presented the president with a memorandum strongly urging him to issue a proclamation freeing the slaves in the South. To add biblical force to their plea, they likened Lincoln to Queen Esther, and reminded him of Mordechai's timeless exhortation spurring her to act:

At the time of the national peril of the Jews under Ahasuerus, Mordechai spake in their name to Queen Esther, who hesitated to take the step necessary to their preservation. "Think not with thyself that thou shalt escape in the king's house, more than all the Jews. For if thou altogether holdest thy peace at this time, then shall there enlargement and deliverance arise to the Jews from another place; but thou and thy father's house shall be destroyed; and who knoweth whether thou art come to the kingdom for such a time as this?"

The clergymen were addressing Lincoln, in other words, with the challenge that Mordechai had addressed to Esther: Why have you been raised to such eminence if not to act now in a great cause and boldly "free the bondman and save the nation"? What they didn't know was that Lincoln needed no persuasion. "[T]he Emancipation Proclamation had already been sitting in a drawer for many weeks," Soloveichik notes, "but Lincoln knew that short of a battlefield victory it would have no effect." Four days later came word of the victory he was waiting for — the bloody battle of Antietam, where Union forces under Gen. George McClellan turned back Gen. Robert E. Lee's invasion of Maryland. Recognizing that the moment was propitious, Lincoln issued his proclamation, dramatically changing the course of history.

There is much, much more to this collection, including essays on how Esther has been portrayed in American art and in children's books, one by historian Tevi Troy comparing palace intrigues in Esther's day with those in the modern White House, and a wholly unexpected study of Mordechai's role as a foster parent to the orphaned Esther that begins with the dedication of an orphanage in New York City in 1863.

Like every great biblical narrative, the Book of Esther is a product of its age that has remained relevant through all the ages. It is not surprising that it has had such resonance in America, a nation whose founders were indelibly shaped by the Hebrew scripture. "You don't have to be Jewish to love Levy's," proclaimed a famous 1960s marketing campaign for kosher rye bread.

Esther in America is proof that you have never had to be Jewish to be enriched and inspired by the story of Esther, the festival of Purim, or the Biblical book that tells their unforgettable story.

( Buy "Esther in America" In hardcover at a discount! by clicking here or order in KINDLE edition at a (72% discount by clicking here. Sales help fund JWR.)


Jeff Jacoby is a columnist for The Boston Globe, from which this is reprinted with permission."