Clicking on banner ads enables JWR to constantly improve
Jewish World Review Dec. 4, 2000 / 7 Kislev 5761

Philip Terzian

JWR's Pundits
World Editorial
Cartoon Showcase

Mallard Fillmore

Michael Barone
Mona Charen
Linda Chavez
Ann Coulter
Greg Crosby
Larry Elder
Don Feder
Suzanne Fields
James Glassman
Paul Greenberg
Bob Greene
Betsy Hart
Nat Hentoff
David Horowitz
Marianne Jennings
Michael Kelly
Mort Kondracke
Ch. Krauthammer
Lawrence Kudlow
Dr. Laura
John Leo
David Limbaugh
Michelle Malkin
Jackie Mason
Michael Medved
Kathleen Parker
Wes Pruden
Debbie Schlussel
Sam Schulman
Amity Shlaes
Roger Simon
Tony Snow
Thomas Sowell
Cal Thomas
Jonathan S. Tobin
Ben Wattenberg
George Will
Bruce Williams
Walter Williams
Mort Zuckerman

Consumer Reports

Downey behind bars -- ROBERT DOWNEY JR. is described in The Washington Post as "one of his generation's most brilliant actors" -- a ubiquitous cliche, along with "comic genius" -- and like many "brilliant" people, his intelligence has failed him in other realms of life.

Having been released in August after a year spent in a tough California prison for possession and use of drugs, he was arrested last week at a hotel in Palm Springs. An anonymous tipster telephoned police to check Downey's room for drugs and guns, and there the cops found cocaine, methamphetamines and no guns, but a manifestly zonked-out Downey. He was handcuffed, transported to jail, and bailed out the following morning. He faces a court hearing two days after Christmas, and because he is a repeat offender and parole violator, is likely to be returned to prison.

Hollywood being Hollywood, the predominate reaction to this story has been practical: Downey's career is in jeopardy, we are told, perhaps finished. It may well be. One of his generation's most brilliant actors is in the middle of a guest appearance on TV's "Ally McBeal," and was about to make a movie with Billy Crystal and Catherine Zeta-Jones. This is not the stuff of great art, to be sure, but it does suggest that Downey is capable of functioning in show business. The two remaining episodes of "Ally McBeal" are now being filmed, but if Downey is in prison next year, Catherine Zeta-Jones will have to find another leading man.

I should point out, for the record, that I once encountered Robert Downey Jr. at a political convention, and found him thoroughly distasteful. But it is impossible to take any guilty pleasure in observing his downward spiral. He is clearly sick, out of touch with reality, and headed toward very hrd times, or disaster.

This is not an unfamiliar story in Hollywood. I used to have a fascination with an early silent star named Wallace Reid, who died in 1923 after a long and well-publicized struggle with narcotics. Rummaging around in the Reid file at the Los Angeles Times (where I was employed at the time) I came across voluminous reporters' notes about the problems movie studios were having keeping dope dealers away from the actors and actresses. That was 80 years ago. Drugs have blighted many lives and careers in subsequent decades, and as Downey's case suggests, will continue to do so.

It is entirely possible, it is entirely likely, that nothing can be done about Downey's problem. In that sense, drug addiction resembles alcoholism: Some recover their lives, and others do not. Accordingly, it's hard to tell the difference between alcoholism and drug addiction -- except, of course, that the possession and consumption of booze is not unlawful. Yet drug addicts are not just treated the same way as criminal predators (Downey shared prison space with Charles Manson, among others) but in roughly comparable numbers as well. Between the state and federal prison systems, there are now over a half-million drug offenders incarcerated in America. Some of these, no doubt, are pushers and big-time dealers, but the vast majority are small-time consumers, or addicts like Downey.

The rationale for putting Charles Manson behind bars is evident enough, but who are we protecting from Robert Downey? The only victim of his behavior is Downey himself. Obviously, when people drive under the influence of alcohol, or are drunk and disorderly in public, they are breaking the law. By the same token, when an addict commits a crime to feed his habit, he needs to face sanctions. But there is no evidence that Downey robbed anyone except himself to acquire drugs, and his conduct in that Palm Springs hotel intruded on no one.

The solution is not to treat alcohol in the same way we approach drugs * that was tried uring 1919-33 -- but to ponder the lessons of the failure of Prohibition. For the past three decades we have been waging a "war on drugs" in America, and after interdiction, K-12 propaganda in the schools, the expenditure of tens of billions of federal dollars, and a doubling and tripling of national prison space, what have we to show for it? The problem is not just persistent, but probably permanent.

There are no simple, comprehensive solutions, and spending more money isn't the answer. Treatment works for some addicts, but not all: Robert Downey, for example, seems to defy all attempts to be cured. But just as we live with the fact that Americans consume alcohol in varying degrees -- from ladies sipping sherry to derelicts in the gutter -- it seems reasonable to suppose that drugs might be comparably tolerated. On the whole, people would be better off if they didn't drink or take drugs. But people, as it turns out, are only human beings; and tossing them into prison for their appetites is futile.

JWR contributor Philip Terzian is associate editor of The Providence Journal. Comment by clicking here.


11/29/00: By any means necessary
11/16/00: Government sanctioned historical revisionism?
11/10/00: Breaking news: They don't know
11/09/00: Steve Allen: Smart TV
11/07/00: The November surprise
11/01/00: Take the Lieberman test
10/30/00: P.S. Don't tell Congress!
10/25/00: The election is close, but ...
10/23/00: King or jester?
10/19/00: The Million T-Shirt March
10/16/00: I like (fill in the blank)
10/12/00: Now comes the hard part
10/05/00: Good show, bad sports
10/02/00: It's a wonderful life?
09/28/00: Driving on America's Main Street
09/22/00: Preparing for a new administration
09/20/00: They've got a secret
09/18/00: Today, Dr. Laura. Tomorrow ...
09/12/00: What passes for knowledge
09/05/00: The catcher gets caught
08/31/00: A Golden Age that never was
08/28/00: Blame communism, not Russia
08/24/00: Social progress on one front, regression on the other
08/21/00: The beat goes awry
08/17/00: The unwelcome democrat

© 2000, The Providence Journal