JWR publishes hundreds of right-thinking columnists and cartoonists. Sign up for the daily update. It's free. Just click here.
Jewish World Review June 6, 2005 / 28 Iyar,
Hurting your country
So how did the USA go from being a beacon of freedom to a
champion of the gulag? How exactly did that happen? Well, pull up a chair,
here's what happened.
After President Bush won reelection last November, there was
much consternation among some powerful anti-Bush Americans. They were
stunned that John Kerry lost and feared that if Bush succeeds in his second
term, the Democrats would lose again in 2008.
Then came the successful election in Iraq, and the fear on the
Left multiplied. If Iraq turned out to be a success, Mr. Bush would become a
hero. So the need to undermine the Bush administration became more intense
than ever. But how to do it? Social Security wasn't emotional enough,
particularly for young voters. What could be done to hurt Bush?
Then came the revelation: Let's torture the president.
The New York Times had already primed the pump, running more
than 50 front-page stories on the abuses at Abu Gharib. Then came reports
from the International Red Cross that more abuse was happening at
Guantanamo. The American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) was already
challenging detentions there, and so a strategy was sealed: The Bush
administration was full of torturers and human rights violators. It was
ruining America's reputation throughout the world. Bush was a villain.
It was easy to get that thesis out. The left-wing websites fed
anti-Bush columnists like Bob Herbert and Richard Cohen information, and the
drumbeat intensified. There was torture and abuse and murder all sanctioned
by the evil Bush administration. Article after article appeared, and soon,
some TV people followed along. It didn't take long before the torture seed
was fully sown.
The Newsweek debacle slowed things down a little, but the
anti-Bush press quickly banded together and pronounced Newsweek's mistake
would never have happened if Bush weren't torturing everybody. I'm sure you
read those opinion pieces as they appeared in liberal newspapers all over
the country. The theme and wording were so similar that one person could
have written all of those articles. And that was no accident.
All the while this was happening, the president and his crew
were doing what they usually do when the press pounds them: nothing. They
did not engage the abuse propaganda until it was obvious Newsweek had
screwed up. But even that effort was derided by many in The White House
press corps, who chided the administration for scolding Newsweek.
Now the torture theme has new momentum. A liberal federal judge
in New York City has ruled the Defense Department must release more photos
and videos of Abu Ghraib to the ACLU. Of course, that will incite even more
hatred against the USA and put our soldiers in more danger, but, hey,
politics comes before protecting the troops. The anti-Bush people want those
pictures almost as badly as Al Jazeera wants them. Another nail in the
president's coffin is more important than bodies in real coffins.
The truth is that abuse has occurred but on a relatively small
scale. According to General Richard Myers, chairman of the Joint Chiefs of
Staff, the United States has detained about 68,000 people since 9/11 (most
have been released), and there have been 325 investigations into alleged
abuse. At this writing, about 100 cases of wrongdoing have been
That's not a big number, but it doesn't matter to the anti-Bush
cabal, which understands that perception is reality in a nation where
"reality programming" is the rage of the day. If you can sell the nation
that America is now a war criminal, President Hillary Clinton is a real
So there you have it. For the anti-Bush folks it is simple: no
pain, no gain. Torture is selling, and the media is buying. For those of you
who are appalled by this analysis, I can only say one thing: Sometimes the
truth, like torture, hurts.
Enjoy this writer's work? Why not sign-up for the daily JWR update. It's free. Just click here.