Jewish World Review Sept. 28, 2001 / 11 Tishrei, 5762

Jules Witcover

Jules Witcover
JWR's Pundits
World Editorial
Cartoon Showcase

Mallard Fillmore

Michael Barone
Mona Charen
Linda Chavez
Ann Coulter
Greg Crosby
Larry Elder
Don Feder
Suzanne Fields
Paul Greenberg
Bob Greene
Betsy Hart
Nat Hentoff
David Horowitz
Marianne Jennings
Michael Kelly
Mort Kondracke
Ch. Krauthammer
Lawrence Kudlow
Dr. Laura
John Leo
David Limbaugh
Michelle Malkin
Chris Matthews
Michael Medved
Kathleen Parker
Wes Pruden
Sam Schulman
Amity Shlaes
Tony Snow
Thomas Sowell
Cal Thomas
Jonathan S. Tobin
Ben Wattenberg
George Will
Bruce Williams
Walter Williams
Mort Zuckerman

Consumer Reports

Muzzling the Voice Of America -- CIVIL liberties groups are concerned about the Justice Department's request to Congress for greatly expanded powers to fight terrorism. While they're at it, they would do well to consider the State Department's attempted muzzling the other day of the Voice of America as part of the same fight.

At issue was an exclusive VOA interview with Mullah Mohammad Omar, head of the Taliban regime in Afghanistan. In it, Omar repeated that the Taliban would not turn over suspected terrorist leader Osama bin Laden and asserted that "America has created the evil that is attacking it."

Before the interview could be aired, State Department officials got members of the VOA's board of governors to kill it. Department spokesman Richard Boucher said it wasn't "appropriate" for the Voice, federally financed but supposedly independent of the department, "to be broadcasting the voice of the Taliban into Afghanistan," and not "consistent with their charter."

Only a brief voice clip of the interview was used along with parts of another with an anti-Taliban spokesman. It subsequently was leaked to CNN and newspapers, and more than 150 VOA staff members, expressing outrage, signed and sent a petition to the board, charging censorship.

VOA, over the State Department's objection, finally did air the report, including parts of the Omar interview. Boucher said State "regrets" the action as not "in the tradition" of the VOA and will "look into" the defiance.

At one point earlier, a mass resignation of VOA reporters and editors was threatened. One senior editor told me: "We're taking this one step at a time. We've made our point. We hope they (the board of governors) have learned a lesson." The VOA, once under the jurisdiction of the State Department, got its own charter from Congress in 1976. In 1999 it was moved from the department and an overseeing board of governors was appointed with State Department representation. The charter stipulates that VOA be a "reliable and authoritative source of news" that is "accurate, objective and comprehensive."

In a staff memo, VOA's news chief, Andrew deNesera, called State's action "a systematic attack on the VOA" and its charter. He praised the staff for landing "a worldwide scoop. ... Networks, newspapers and wire services can only dream of such an interview," he wrote. "We got it." But instead of praising VOA, he went on, State "quashed the interview, using the dubious reasoning that 'you don't give a platform to terrorists.'"

He called the action a "totally unacceptable assault on our editorial independence, a frontal attack on our credibility" and "a dark, dark day for those of us who have, for years, fought to uphold journalistic ethics, balance, accuracy and fairness."

VOA's acting director, Myrna Whitworth, also wrote to the staff, urging its members "NOT to fall under the spell of 'self-censorship.' If you do, 'they' have won." She called on them to "continue to interview ANYONE, ANYWHERE."

The initial muzzling came in the wake of a New York Times column by William Safire headlined "Equal Time for Hitler?" in which he castigated VOA for airing another interview with another Islamic leader he said had ties with a terrorist group.

"VOA is the wrong voice in this area in wartime," he wrote. He called for a greater role toward Afghanistan for Radio Free Europe, another federally supported news agency with a more specific mission of disseminating American political perspectives abroad.

Criticizing VOA for being "even-handed' when "the nation is on a kind of war footing," Safire observed that "even in peacetime, news credibility does not flow from splitting the moral difference between good and evil. In the climate of today's undeclared war, private media in democracies are free to take either or neither side, but U.S. taxpayer-supported broadcasting is supposed to be on our side."

But the responsibility of any credible news organization is to gather information wherever it can be found and report it, rather than propagandize in behalf of "our side." As a one-time publicist and speechwriter for Richard Nixon and Spiro Agnew, Safire can be forgiven for not appreciating the difference, even now as he adopts the journalist's cloak.

Comment on JWR contributor Jules Witcover's column by clicking here.

09/26/01: Bush's transformation
09/24/01: Using a tragedy for a federal bailout
09/21/01: A view of tragedy at home from abroad
09/14/01: Script for AlGore's coming-out party
08/31/01: Scandal and privacy in politics
08/24/01: On replacing Helms
08/22/01: Politics takes a summer holiday
08/15/01: The resurfacing of AlGore
08/13/01: You can go home again
08/10/01: Governors' Conference drought
08/08/01: Governors defend their turf
08/06/01: New Bush muscle with congress
08/03/01: America's benign neglect
07/30/01: Where is the fear factor?
07/26/01: Dubya, Nancy Reagan and the Pope
07/23/01: Bush's congressional dilemma
07/19/01: Katharine Graham, giant
07/11/01: Finessing election reform
07/09/01: Listening to, and watching, Ashcroft
07/06/01: New comedian in the House (of Representatives)
06/27/01: Spinning Campaign Finance Reform's latest 'headway'
06/25/01: When Dubya says 'the check is in the mail,' you can believe him
06/22/01: The push on patients' rights
06/20/01: If you can't trust historians, how can you trust history?
06/18/01: World Refugee Day
06/13/01: Remembering 'Hubert'
06/11/01: Ventura faces government shutdown
06/06/01: McCain doth protest too much
06/04/01: Memo to the Bush daughters
05/30/01: Missing in action: Democratic outrage
05/30/01: Honoring World War II vets
05/23/01: Lauding the Nixon pardon
05/21/01: Messin' with McCain
05/18/01: A great movie plot
05/16/01: The level of public sensibility these days
05/14/01: "I am Al Gore. I used to be the next president of the United States"

© 2001, TMS