Jewish World Review April 25, 2003 / 23 Nisan, 5763

Terry Eastland

Eastland
JWR's Pundits
World Editorial
Cartoon Showcase

Mallard Fillmore

Michael Barone
Mona Charen
Linda Chavez
Ann Coulter
Greg Crosby
Larry Elder
Don Feder
Suzanne Fields
James Glassman
Paul Greenberg
Bob Greene
Betsy Hart
Nat Hentoff
David Horowitz
Marianne Jennings
Michael Kelly
Mort Kondracke
Ch. Krauthammer
Lawrence Kudlow
Dr. Laura
John Leo
Michelle Malkin
Jackie Mason
Chris Matthews
Michael Medved
MUGGER
Kathleen Parker
Wes Pruden
Sam Schulman
Amity Shlaes
Roger Simon
Tony Snow
Thomas Sowell
Cal Thomas
Jonathan S. Tobin
Ben Wattenberg
George Will
Bruce Williams
Walter Williams
Mort Zuckerman

Consumer Reports


Another April that mattered


http://www.NewsAndOpinion.com | Historians will look back at this month and regard it as one of our nation's most important ever. April 2003 will be seen as the month in which we toppled a regime that tyrannized its own people and was a threat to its region and even beyond it. We don't know what the liberation of Iraq will fully mean for the Iraqi people, nor what impact it will have elsewhere in the Middle East. But April 2003 is the month in which we spared the world from further atrocities ordered by Saddam Hussein.

A big accomplishment, yes, but another April - in 1865 - remains even more significant. Two years ago, the historian Jay Winik published his best-selling book, " April 1865". (CLICK ON LINK TO BUY). That was the month the Civil War ended, and it remains so important because during that month the nation didn't implode, as indeed it might have, but survived. It was, as Mr. Winik's subtitle puts it, "The Month That Saved America."

Now, the History Channel, drawing on Mr. Winik's book, has re-created that amazing April. Its April 1865 premiered earlier this month and will air a second time on Saturday.

The book remains primary but the documentary, a production of Triage Entertainment Inc., is very good. The writers came up with a narrative that respects the integrity of Mr. Winik's book, and the producers made it into a film that certainly keeps your attention.

The History Channel likes to re-create events, and with the Civil War, of course, there is no shortage of grown men willing to suit up in the uniforms of 1865 and re-enact a battle or two. The re-enactments used in April 1865 don't overwhelm it but are just long enough to make the necessary historical points.

Silently effective are the old photos of Robert E. Lee, Ulysses S. Grant and Abraham Lincoln, among others, that appear throughout the film. The music isn't as melancholy as it often is in Civil War films and at times seems too upbeat. The talking heads - Mr. Winik, Gary Gallagher of the University of Virginia and Donald Miller of Lafayette College - are used just as they should be: to emphasize and to sum up.

The History Channel understands itself as an educator and is encouraging classroom use of April 1865, having prepared a teacher's guide. May schools across America now darken rooms for viewing: The documentary covers well the three great events of that month - the fall of Richmond, Lee's retreat and surrender at Appomattox and Lincoln's assassination. But most important of all, it conveys the central point of Mr. Winik's book - that events that now appear to us as "inevitable" were anything but that to those who lived through that momentous month.

Like the book, the film teaches the contingencies of history: We see Lee's hungry army in retreat, its hopes of regrouping dashed when a train that was supposed to be full of food is stacked with ammunition. What if, we are invited to wonder, the food had been there?

Also like the book, the film teaches the importance of human choice: We see Lee's army finally trapped, the indomitable general deciding what to do next. He chooses, we know, to lay down arms. But what if he had decided - as we see was urged on him - to head west for the mountains and mount a guerrilla resistance?

"The whole of our national history could have been altered," writes Mr. Winik in April 1865, "but for a few decisions, a quirk of fate or a sudden shift of luck."

The History Channel deserves credit for making into a film Jay Winik's engrossing narrative about the final month of the Civil War. Had America not been saved that month, we wouldn't be where we are today - nor, it bears emphasizing, would history around the world, including in Iraq, have been the same.

Appreciate this writer's work? Why not sign-up for JWR's daily update. It's free. Just click here.




JWR contributor Terry Eastland is is publisher of The Weekly Standard.Comment by clicking here.

04/16/03: Is it acceptable for an education secretary to state a personal preference for religious schooling?
04/08/03: University officials must put academics ahead of athletics
04/02/03: Support for our soldiers means support for their orders
03/27/03: 'Free Iraqi Forces' underscore Bush's sincerity
03/18/03: Dems misunderstand judge's job
03/13/03: Justices show right restraint in ruling on anti-crime measures
03/05/03: America's imperial intentions
02/25/03: The weakness of Dems' stated reason for their filibuster makes you wonder whether it is the real reason
02/19/03: Administration fine-tunes religious rights in public education
02/12/03: France and Germany need to be reminded of the necessity of a strong, even predominant America
02/06/03: Judiciary's 'balance' -- or lack of it -- is our doing
01/29/03: The child who almost wasn't
01/21/03: President decides to punt on affirmative action case
01/14/03: Bush's faith has influenced his conduct in public office
01/07/03: Dems need ideas, not more microphones
12/17/02: Gray Lady should learn that times have changed
12/10/02: Will High Court be guilty of activism?
12/03/02: The missing facts in news accounts of Saudi Princess Haifa's putative 'charity'
11/26/02: Americans don't have to be worried about Big Brother
11/19/02: Texas' reputation for flamboyance may be revised
11/11/02: Bush now can repair confirmation system
11/05/02: Dems shouldn't believe too strongly in history
10/30/02: Snipers had lots of motives
10/23/02: No one should be shut out of marketplace of ideas
10/15/02: Open hearings that could imperil the nation
10/08/02: Debating the clear and present danger
10/01/02: A great awakening in China?
09/25/02: Abortion, again? The settled but still unsettling law of Roe v. Wade
09/18/02: A relevant presidency--and irrelevant U.N?
09/10/02: Ashcroft's obtuse judicial statement
09/04/02: The Education Gadfly stings again
08/28/02: So then let the president declare war
08/21/02: Will Bush finally 'fix' affirmative action once and for all?
08/06/02: President must take up cause of Egyptian democracy warrior
07/31/02: With each war, civil liberties are curtailed less

© 2002, Terry Eastland