Jewish World Review March 3, 2003 / 29 Adar I, 5763

PunditWatch

PunditWatch
JWR's Pundits
World Editorial
Cartoon Showcase

Mallard Fillmore

Michael Barone
Mona Charen
Linda Chavez
Ann Coulter
Greg Crosby
Larry Elder
Don Feder
Suzanne Fields
James Glassman
Paul Greenberg
Bob Greene
Betsy Hart
Nat Hentoff
David Horowitz
Marianne Jennings
Michael Kelly
Mort Kondracke
Ch. Krauthammer
Lawrence Kudlow
Dr. Laura
John Leo
Michelle Malkin
Jackie Mason
Chris Matthews
Michael Medved
MUGGER
Kathleen Parker
Wes Pruden
Sam Schulman
Amity Shlaes
Roger Simon
Tony Snow
Thomas Sowell
Cal Thomas
Jonathan S. Tobin
Ben Wattenberg
George Will
Bruce Williams
Walter Williams
Mort Zuckerman

Consumer Reports


Anti-War Guests Win 'Most Improved' Award


http://www.NewsAndOpinion.com | Last week's Sunday shows featured anti-war Hollywood activists and a marginal presidential candidate. The reviews were decidedly mixed, so this week's anti-war guests were a more serious lot and the debates proved more illuminating.

Gone were actress Susan Sarandon, comedienne Janeane Garafolo, and Congressman Dennis Kucinich. In their place were Win Without War Director Tom Andrews, presidential candidate Gov. Howard Dean, and French Foreign Minister Dominique de Villepin. Actor Mike Farrell made the cut, returning for a second week.

Meet the Press host Tim Russert demonstrated impressive balance as he first moderated a debate between Sen. Lindsay Graham, R-SC, and Andrews, followed by a debate between Farrell and pro-war actor turned Senator turned actor Fred Thompson, R-Tenn. Graham was the most entertaining guest, calling the French and Germans "appeasers" and accusing those serving as "human shields" in Iraq of committing an "act of treason."

Farrell and Andrews stood their ground on continued UN inspections as the best policy. "Hans Blix tells us we are making progress. We are destroying missiles as we speak. No one has to die," said Andrews. Sen. Thompson was much less effective as a guest than in his televised ad supporting the President.

George Stephanopolous conducted a fair but aggressive interview with de Villepin on This Week, drawing an admiring comment from Sen. John Warner, R-VA: "You pressed him hard and he stonewalled you." The position of de Villepin was almost indistinguishable from that of US anti-war leaders. "There is an alternative to war-inspectors. How many American boys are going to die in Iraq? Is it worth it?"

The French Foreign Minister refused to say if France would use its veto on another resolution at the UN. Stephanopolous asked what he would say if US troops invaded Iraq and discovered a huge cache of chemical or biological weapons. "We should have given more time to inspectors," said de Villepin.

Former Vermont Gov. Dean, feeling "the big 'mo'" as his anti-war message continues to be well-received, appeared on Face the Nation and sounded extremely bellicose on everything but Iraq. He favored more funding to the CIA, agreed with assassinations as long as they were not of heads of state, criticized FBI Director Robert Mueller, and seemed to support unilateral action against North Korea and Iran.

HOW BIG WAS IT?

Most shows began with a recap of the Khalid Sheik Mohammed capture and guests were asked for their reaction:

Howard Dean, on Face the Nation: "A real coup."

Sen. Pat Roberts, R-Kan, on Fox: "He's the big fish, the king fish, he's the Operations Manager."

Sen. Joe Biden, D-Del, on Fox: "This is a phenomenal development. A significant breakthrough."

Winner of the hyperbole award, however, is Rep. Porter Goss, R-FL, on This Week: "This is a very huge event, the equivalent of the liberation of Paris in the Second World War."

WALKING AND CHEWING GUM

Many pundits used the capture of Khalid Sheik Mohammed to discredit one anti-war argument-that focusing on Iraq limits the War on Terror. Kate O'Beirne of the National Review, on Capital Gang, was the strongest:

"It seems to me the administration's case about whether to remove Saddam Hussein got stronger today. The arrest of Khalid Sheik Mohammed was a huge arrest that the CIA, FBI, and Pakistani intelligence cooperated in. Those who've been wondering, Can the United States lead a war to get rid of Saddam Hussein while fighting an effective war against al Qaeda? It seems to me his arrest is an emphatic yes to that question."

Surprisingly, only Fox host Tony Snow pressed a guest on this topic, getting Sen. Biden to suggest that he would have supported 200,000 troops on the Afghanistan-Pakistan border.

BIDEN BASHES, WARNER RETHINKS

On Fox, Sen. Biden also accused the French of "grandstanding" and said dismissively, "The French care so much about the Palestinians, but they don't give a damn about the Iraqis." Sen. Warner, on This Week, said he considered taking down the Croix de Guerre in his office that his father won in WWI, but decided against it.

SHAMELESS PROMO OF THE WEEK

Retired NATO Commander General Joe Ralston was introduced as a guest on Face the Nation and as a new CBS consultant. "You're moving from one good outfit to another," said host Bob Scheiffer.

SURREAL NEWS HOUR

Paul Gigot, editorial page editor of the Wall Street Journal, returned to The News Hour to sub for David Brooks. He claimed "I'm really actually pleased that there is an awful lot of debate and discussion about this," referring to anti-war demonstrations, while syndicated columnist Mark Shields approvingly quoted Roy Cohn, former chief counsel to Sen. Joseph McCarthy.

ORANGE EXPLANATION

Gigot also appeared on the Fox panel and claimed the recent Orange terror alert was related to intelligence that later led to the capture of Khalid Sheik Mohammed.

WAR REPORTING

The Capital Gang looked at the Pentagon's policy of "embedding" the press into military units to cover the possible war with Iraq. Veteran Knight-Ridder reporter Joseph Galloway was asked if this was a good idea: "There's no way to roam, really, independently in a place like Iraq, with tank divisions attacking. And if you've got a lot of journalists running around there loose on their own in SUVs, a lot of them are going to get killed."

GEORGE KNOWS THIS ANGLE

ABC's Michel Martin complained that President Bush gave his speech on the future of Iraq to an "interest group" (the American Enterprise Institute) instead of a more diverse audience, but George Stephanopolous disagreed, praising the White House's effectiveness in convincing the networks to televise it.

QUIPS OF THE WEEK

Brit Hume, on Fox: "If I die, I'd like to come back as Hans Blix's son. You'd never be in any trouble. Any effort would be good enough. Grades would never be bad enough to get you in any trouble. It would be great."

Margaret Carlson, Time, on Capital Gang, speaking of just-declared presidential candidate Sen. Bob Graham, D-FL: "The Democrats, instead of having a smoke- filled room, are having their candidates come by way of an ICU. If he puts his heart into it, he'll be a serious candidate."

Enjoy this writer's work? Why not sign-up for the daily JWR update. It's free. Just click here.




PunditWatch is written by JWR contributor Will Vehrs. Comment by clicking here.

02/24/03: Anti-war side makes their case
02/10/03: Pundits review Powell's performance
02/03/03: Columbia Freezes Partisan Debates
01/27/03: Pundits Pass on Preview
01/21/03: Michigan Case Leads Peace Marches
01/13/03: Frist Debuts as Sunday Star
01/06/03: Back to the fun and games!
12/30/02: Peripatetic Powell pacifies pundits
12/23/02: A Lott to let go before Fristing
12/16/02: Lott jury and flogging post
12/09/02: Issues overwhelm pundits
12/02/02: Real news and pundit news
11/25/02: In a muddle, Saudis rise to the top

Up

© 2002, Will Vehrs