Clicking on banner ads enables JWR to constantly improve
Jewish World Review Dec. 19, 2002 / 14 Teves, 5763

Matt Towery

JWR's Pundits
World Editorial
Cartoon Showcase

Mallard Fillmore

Michael Barone
Mona Charen
Linda Chavez
Ann Coulter
Greg Crosby
Larry Elder
Don Feder
Suzanne Fields
James Glassman
Paul Greenberg
Bob Greene
Betsy Hart
Nat Hentoff
David Horowitz
Marianne Jennings
Michael Kelly
Mort Kondracke
Ch. Krauthammer
Lawrence Kudlow
Dr. Laura
John Leo
Michelle Malkin
Jackie Mason
Chris Matthews
Michael Medved
Kathleen Parker
Wes Pruden
Sam Schulman
Amity Shlaes
Roger Simon
Tony Snow
Thomas Sowell
Cal Thomas
Jonathan S. Tobin
Ben Wattenberg
George Will
Bruce Williams
Walter Williams
Mort Zuckerman

Consumer Reports

We ain't all rednecks, y'know! | The smoldering controversy over racially insensitive statements made by Sen. Trent Lott has been elevated to the status of a fare-thee-well wish toward the Mississippi Republican by large contingents among civil rights leaders, Democrats, Republicans and the media.

I have nothing to add with regard to Lott's misguided comments. But while we are at work collectively criticizing bigoted statements and impugning motives, it's instructive to note that many leading media commentators took to the airwaves this past week and -- apparently with little reflection and no sense of irony or hypocrisy -- revealed once again their own ever-present bias and bigotry toward Southerners. Presumably as an antidote to Lott's obtuse praising of centenarian Sen. Strom Thurmond of South Carolina -- a long-ago segregationist -- one national TV program on Sunday asked a group of political and journalistic gurus whether the policies of President George W. Bush were, in essence, an embracing of the supposed backward worldview of the South. Talk about a callous, cavalier outlook!

The fact that most who engaged in similar TV chitchat over the past few days meant no offense just goes to illustrate their unconscious ignorance of what does and does not comprise the modern South.

It's easy to talk about racial issues when one is enveloped in a cocoon with other Washington insiders or Hollywood artists. But these self-assumed social and racial experts discount the fact that most Southern states have a much higher percentage of African Americans than do their allegedly more progressive sister states. Beyond that, census information reveals that more and more blacks are leaving supposedly more progressive regions to relocate to the South.

Why would African Americans risk the expected insults, indignities, and social and professional exclusions of living in the former Dixie? Because even though instances of racial discrimination linger in the South -- as elsewhere -- the bigger story is that the region has witnessed an admirable, underreported transformation. Many Southern cities are more racially progressive than their Northern or Western counterparts.

In Dallas, Houston, Atlanta, Jacksonville, Fla., New Orleans, and many other big towns, a burgeoning African-American middle and upper class has emerged with an attendant political leadership to reflect it. Blacks, in fact, often dominate the political cultures of these cities, and make up ever more of their economic heft.

And counter to the mostly unspoken assumption of so much national media, most Southerners don't obsess over "how to keep blacks down." Such a sentiment would pollute many a working environment in which Southern whites spend toiling alongside African Americans, as well as Asians, Hispanics and other "minorities" (to me, a term that itself belittles). And when not working with blacks, many Southern whites are entertaining them, or -- as in the case of my own son -- inviting them to a weekend sleepover. For many of us -- yes, even those who tend to support those Southern Republicans -- the notion that among our friends might be a black one isn't really a cause for consideration. It certainly isn't for my son, of whom I am proud.

This column isn't an attempt to whitewash the fact that vestiges of bigotry don't still exist in the South. But they also manifest themselves everywhere from Boston to Seattle.

Those of us who live in the South aren't perfect. We sometimes say and do stupid things. But it would serve the pundits well to think twice before intentionally or unwittingly denigrating an entire region of the nation -- and a growing one at that.

Seems that I've recently read about a fellow Southerner -- one Jimmy Carter -- accepting a Nobel Peace Prize. Maybe there's more to a Southern upbringing than is commonly supposed.

Enjoy this writer's work? Why not sign-up for the daily JWR update. It's free. Just click here.

Comment on JWR columnist Matt Towery's column by clicking here.

12/11/02: Time to put some post-9/11 energy into solving our domestic woes
12/04/02: Henry Kissinger's Earl Warren problem
11/13/02: Where a forceful president belongs
11/06/02: Once again, America will be the bad guy
10/25/02: Jeb's campaign is sinking and it will impact the GOP nationwide
10/18/02: Weighing election scenarios
10/11/02: Jeb's future
10/03/02: Pity the once-popular governors
09/26/02: Electronic train wrecks that stain people's lives
09/19/02: Floridians take themselves seriously
09/13/02: Don't dither, Dubya
09/05/02: Should Jeb really be concerned?
08/28/02: The dynamics of defeat? Florida governor's race could have national implications
08/21/02: Unsure Americans
08/15/02: A white, Southerner faces discrimination at sports dome
08/08/02: The hidden story in the Reno v. Bush race
08/05/02: McKinney, 9-11 conspiracy theorist, in fight for political life
07/31/02: GOP quietly shoring-up domestic policies
07/25/02: Media snobs need to look beyond New York, D.C.
07/18/02: A letter to President Bush from Outside the Beltway
07/11/02: Dear President Bush: An effort in futility
07/03/02: Updates and freedom
06/27/02: The coming election: Seeking change for the sake of change?
06/20/02: The inside story re the political future of controversial GOPer Bob Barr
06/11/02: On dirty bombs and scare-mongering: Sometimes a columnist wishes he was wrong
06/06/02: The emerging confused GOPer?
05/30/02: In search of an aggressive GOP leader
05/21/02: Anticipating new terrorism: "Dirty bomb" is no fantasy!
05/16/02: The oddity of Carter's legacy
05/09/02: Replay of 1992 coming?
05/02/02: The hottest family on television might have to abandon the United States
04/25/02: One step ahead of devious minds capable of unthinkable crimes?
04/18/02: Alaskan battleground?
04/11/02: How the peaceful fairways of the world's most revered golf course, may serve as a brilliant strategic battleground the most recent round of "cola wars"
04/05/02: The most likely immediate threat to our national security is being ignored
03/14/02: Clinton's influence looms
03/07/02: Poll turns up surprising views on Bush and more
02/21/02: The recession is over --- so why are the sophisticates still using scare tactics?
02/14/02: This Enron story directly affects our own pocketbooks
02/07/02: The epicenter of quiet but powerful shifts in the American political landscape
01/31/02: A little bipartisan hope
01/24/02: Secrets of the past can often provide guidance for dealing with the future
01/18/02: And I thought explaining Jane Fonda was tough
01/09/02: Dubya falling into Dems' trap?
01/02/02: A few adjustments and 2002 might turn out all right
12/27/01 Rudy, the 'perfect excuse'?
12/19/01 Haig the madman?
12/12/01 That senator with the funny name

© 2001, Creators Syndicate