Clicking on banner ads enables JWR to constantly improve
Jewish World Review Jan. 13, 2003 / 10 Shevat, 5763

Seth Gitell

Gitell
JWR's Pundits
World Editorial
Cartoon Showcase

Mallard Fillmore

Michael Barone
Mona Charen
Linda Chavez
Ann Coulter
Greg Crosby
Larry Elder
Don Feder
Suzanne Fields
James Glassman
Paul Greenberg
Bob Greene
Betsy Hart
Nat Hentoff
David Horowitz
Marianne Jennings
Michael Kelly
Mort Kondracke
Ch. Krauthammer
Lawrence Kudlow
Dr. Laura
John Leo
Michelle Malkin
Jackie Mason
Chris Matthews
Michael Medved
MUGGER
Kathleen Parker
Wes Pruden
Sam Schulman
Amity Shlaes
Roger Simon
Tony Snow
Thomas Sowell
Cal Thomas
Jonathan S. Tobin
Ben Wattenberg
George Will
Bruce Williams
Walter Williams
Mort Zuckerman

Consumer Reports


Lieberman is in a pickle --- and it's becoming increasingly more sour


http://www.NewsAndOpinion.com | Senator Joseph Lieberman is in a pickle. Lieberman wants to run for president and will likely announce his intention to form an exploratory committee as early as today. As a precursor to his run, Lieberman just returned from a fact-finding mission from the Middle East that is drawing fire from those on the right and those on the left. E.J. Kessler, writing in the Forward, reports that hawkish, mostly Orthodox, Jews are angry at Lieberman because he criticized the Bush Administration's policy toward the Middle East and expressed support for a Palestinian state.

"The Orthodox community is troubled by his statements, by his trying to lean over backward for a Palestinian state," Mandell Ganchrow, executive vice president of Religious Zionists of America, told Kessler. The trip, meanwhile, drew the ire of Israel-critic and Web columnist Prima Soho.

In a piece headlined "Senator Lieberman meets his master, Israel," Soho excoriates Lieberman for making a distinction between Israel and Iraq in an interview with the Arab News. "Israel is not a danger to its people and its neighbors in a way that Iraq under Saddam is," Lieberman said. For Soho, Lieberman's comments demonstrate "the official Israeli viewpoint, and that of pro-Israeli lobby groups in the U.S." In other words, says Soho, Lieberman is a tool of Israel.

Putting aside the obvious and simple point that Soho is trotting out the usual anti-Semitic canard about American Jews -- that they are more loyal to Israel than America -- the contrast in the reactions of the two camps is stunning. For Orthodox Jews, Lieberman wasn't pro-Israel enough. For extreme anti-Israel critics, he was too pro-Israel. This is only a taste of what Lieberman has in store for him in a presidential run.

The world has changed since 2000 when Lieberman teamed up with Vice President Al Gore to win the popular vote. The aftermath of September 11 showed that anti-Semitism was once again a powerful force in the world: remember the rumor that swept the Arab world and much of the west that Jews didn't show up to work at the World Trade Center that day? Terrorists forced Wall Street Journal reporter Daniel Pearl to make his last words an admission of his Jewish identity. US policy on Israel has become a hot button dividing issue between America and Europe.

None of this is to suggest Lieberman should not run. The Democratic Party needs his updating of the philosophies of Henry M. "Scoop" Jackson for the modern era. Americans, generally, are free of bias on religious grounds. But Lieberman's Jewish identity will create a special obstacle that he will need to overcome.

Already, he is doing what he can on a personal level. When he is in Washington DC, he has been lingering after Sabbath services at Kesher Israel, his synagogue in Georgetown. (Known informally as Kesher, the synagogue is home to a host of low-key, but important, political activists and attendees such as Leon Wieseltier, the literary editor of the New Republic, Daniel Benjamin, a terrorism expert and the author of The Age of Sacred Terror, and Alfred Moses, a Clinton Administration ambassador to Romania.)

Rather than rushing out of synagogue to make the rest of the 1.5 mile trek back to his home -- observant Jews don't ride in cars on the Sabbath -- Lieberman, always friendly, has been making a special effort to take time after Saturday services and schmooze with regulars. "He was definitely hanging around the Kiddush [a small meal after services] for longer than usual," one worshipper reports. "He's been kibbitzing with everyone -- much longer than before."

Lieberman can hope that his personal charm can outweigh the obstacles to his campaign. But it will be a tough road in these tough days.



JWR contributor Seth Gitell is the political writer of the Boston Phoenix Comment by clicking here.

12/26/02: Where does the war on terror go from here?
12/23/02: Why democracy never came to Iraq after the last Gulf War
12/20/02: Vermont governor Howard Dean hopes to bridge the gulf between New England and the Western states, and bypass the socially conservative South. Should John Kerry be worried?
12/18/02: No Gore 2004: Follow the Money
12/06/02: Gore, like Dicken's Jacob Marley, Dead as a Door-nail
10/24/02: War with Iraq may not happen, after all
10/22/02: Winning European hearts and minds
10/18/02: Lieberman makes 'em laugh --- on purpose
10/04/02: Hawking an interpretation (in which Scott Ritter tells our columnist to 'go to H-LL!')
09/13/02: Bush Challenge to U.N. Members: Are You Better than League of Nations?
09/06/02: Iraq attack: Ritter's reversal
08/30/02: Stick with comedy, Jon Stewart
08/16/02: Green around the gills: Nader Effect could cost the Dems the election in three states
08/01/02: Gore's low profile is no accident
07/31/02: President Hillary? Despite her denials, candidacy is not that unlikely
07/26/02: On the road with John Kerry
07/17/02: Meet the 'Clinton' of the 2004 New Hampshire primary
07/12/02: Ancient rivalry: Williams vs. DiMaggio
07/10/02: Warrior spirit
05/08/02: Hosting a TV show will keep Clinton off the streets
04/26/02: Truth in advertising in SaudiLand --- and ours
02/28/02: Time for hipsters to do a reality-check

© 2002, Seth Gitell