Jewish World Review Jan. 16, 2002 / 3 Shevat, 5762

Jules Witcover

Jules Witcover
JWR's Pundits
World Editorial
Cartoon Showcase

Mallard Fillmore

Michael Barone
Mona Charen
Linda Chavez
Ann Coulter
Greg Crosby
Larry Elder
Don Feder
Suzanne Fields
Paul Greenberg
Bob Greene
Betsy Hart
Nat Hentoff
David Horowitz
Marianne Jennings
Michael Kelly
Mort Kondracke
Ch. Krauthammer
Lawrence Kudlow
Dr. Laura
John Leo
David Limbaugh
Michelle Malkin
Chris Matthews
Michael Medved
Kathleen Parker
Wes Pruden
Sam Schulman
Amity Shlaes
Tony Snow
Thomas Sowell
Cal Thomas
Jonathan S. Tobin
Ben Wattenberg
George Will
Bruce Williams
Walter Williams
Mort Zuckerman

Consumer Reports

On the departure of high government officials -- WHEN most notable public figures depart this veil of tears, they're memorialized for what they did. But when former Secretary of State Cyrus R. Vance made his final exit at age 84 the other day, his obituaries instead featured another celebrated departure, in which what he didn't do rated great attention.

That was when, in April 1980, Vance resigned in protest of the decision of President Jimmy Carter to resort to force in a failed effort to rescue American hostages in Iran.

Quitting the highest appointive executive position in the government was nearly unprecedented in itself. Previously, only William Jennings Bryan had put on his hat and walked out of the State Department on principle. A devout pacifist, Bryan in 1915 quit in protest of President Woodrow Wilson's sharp note to Berlin in the wake of the torpedoing and sinking of the liner Lusitania, in which 124 Americans perished.

What made Vance's principled departure all the more notable was the fact that while he presented his resignation to Carter in advance of the ill-fated mission that ended in the crash of an American helicopter and a cargo plane in the Iranian desert, he did not permit it to be made public until afterward.

Although he disagreed strenuously with the mission as potentially destructive of diplomatic efforts to extricate the American hostages, he declined to throw a monkey wrench into a presidential decision already made. Nor did he engage in any self-serving I-told-you-so afterward.

"You would not be well served in the coming weeks and months," he wrote Carter, "by a secretary of state who could not offer you the public backing you need on an issue and decision of such extraordinary importance, no matter how firm I remain in my support on other issues, as I do, or how loyal I am to you as our leader."

Vance's act went conspicuously against the grain of behavior of nearly all high-level appointed officials before or since. All through the Vietnam experience, for instance, no similar policy-making official ever walked the plank in protest of a war about which many of them held the deepest reservations.

The customary argument for keeping quiet and continuing to serve was either that speaking out would not have changed policy - Hubert Humphrey was a sad example of this rationale as President Lyndon Johnson's vice president - or that a resignation would only lead to the appointment of somebody worse in the job.

Then there was the sorry - some would say tragic - history of LBJ's secretary of defense, Robert S. McNamara, who harbored severe doubts about the continued pursuit of the war he was directing but never came clean on them until years later, in a pathetic mea culpa book.

Another high Pentagon official, John T. McNaughton, an assistant defense secretary under McNamara, was said to be contemplating resignation in open protest against the Vietnam war in 1967 when he was killed in a plane crash. He had just been nominated to be secretary of the Navy.

Another secretary of state, Dean Acheson, also resigned on principle, but he was an undersecretary of the treasury at the time, under President Franklin D. Roosevelt in 1933, in disagreement over FDR's decision to take the country off the gold standard. Acheson, like Vance, left quietly, and when another Treasury official later submitted a rancorous resignation, FDR told his press secretary: "Return it to him and tell him to ask Acheson how a gentleman resigns."

The high government service of neither Acheson nor Vance ended with their resignations on principle. Acheson later became secretary of state under President Harry Truman and Vance as a private citizen successfully undertook a number of critical diplomatic negotiations, including one that brought about a cease-fire in Croatia, clearing the way for a UN peacekeeping force in Yugoslavia.

Both men demonstrated a lesson too seldom learned in Washington - doing what you believe to be right in the face of authority doesn't necessarily mean oblivion, even in politics.

Comment on JWR contributor Jules Witcover's column by clicking here.

01/11/02: The lobbyist as party chairman
01/07/02: Torricelli's clean bill of health
12/12/01: The elevated vice presidency
12/07/01: September 11th and December 7th
12/05/01: Another children's crusade
12/03/01: Stall on campaign finance reform
11/30/01: Stall on campaign finance reform
11/28/01: More Justice Department folly
11/26/01: Ashcroft still under fire
11/21/01: Normalcy vs. security at the White House
11/12/01: Bush's latest pep talk
11/07/01: The blame game on airport security
11/05/01: Bellwether gubernatorial elections?
11/02/01: Feingold's complaint
10/31/01: Putting the cart before the horse?
10/29/01: Show business on economic stimulus
10/26/01: No political business as usual
10/24/01: Senatorial bravado
10/22/01: Split decision on gun rights
10/16/01: New York mayor's race: What kind of experience?
10/15/01: New York: Making a comeback
10/11/01: Giuliani: Fly in the election ointment
10/08/01: One or two New Yorks?
10/05/01: Providing your own security
10/01/01: Getting back to 'normal'
09/28/01: Muzzling the Voice Of America
09/26/01: Bush's transformation
09/24/01: Using a tragedy for a federal bailout
09/21/01: A view of tragedy at home from abroad
09/14/01: Script for AlGore's coming-out party
08/31/01: Scandal and privacy in politics
08/24/01: On replacing Helms
08/22/01: Politics takes a summer holiday
08/15/01: The resurfacing of AlGore
08/13/01: You can go home again
08/10/01: Governors' Conference drought
08/08/01: Governors defend their turf
08/06/01: New Bush muscle with congress
08/03/01: America's benign neglect
07/30/01: Where is the fear factor?
07/26/01: Dubya, Nancy Reagan and the Pope
07/23/01: Bush's congressional dilemma
07/19/01: Katharine Graham, giant
07/11/01: Finessing election reform
07/09/01: Listening to, and watching, Ashcroft
07/06/01: New comedian in the House (of Representatives)
06/27/01: Spinning Campaign Finance Reform's latest 'headway'
06/25/01: When Dubya says 'the check is in the mail,' you can believe him
06/22/01: The push on patients' rights
06/20/01: If you can't trust historians, how can you trust history?
06/18/01: World Refugee Day
06/13/01: Remembering 'Hubert'
06/11/01: Ventura faces government shutdown
06/06/01: McCain doth protest too much
06/04/01: Memo to the Bush daughters
05/30/01: Missing in action: Democratic outrage
05/30/01: Honoring World War II vets
05/23/01: Lauding the Nixon pardon
05/21/01: Messin' with McCain
05/18/01: A great movie plot
05/16/01: The level of public sensibility these days
05/14/01: "I am Al Gore. I used to be the next president of the United States"

© 2001, TMS