Clicking on banner ads enables JWR to constantly improve
Jewish World Review March 28, 2001 / 4 Nissan 5761

Evan Gahr

JWR's Pundits
World Editorial
Cartoon Showcase

Mallard Fillmore

Michael Barone
Mona Charen
Linda Chavez
Greg Crosby
Larry Elder
Don Feder
Suzanne Fields
James Glassman
Paul Greenberg
Bob Greene
Betsy Hart
Nat Hentoff
David Horowitz
Marianne Jennings
Michael Kelly
Mort Kondracke
Ch. Krauthammer
Lawrence Kudlow
Dr. Laura
John Leo
David Limbaugh
Michelle Malkin
Jackie Mason
Chris Matthews
Michael Medved
Kathleen Parker
Wes Pruden
Sam Schulman
Amity Shlaes
Roger Simon
Tony Snow
Thomas Sowell
Cal Thomas
Jonathan S. Tobin
Ben Wattenberg
George Will
Bruce Williams
Walter Williams
Mort Zuckerman

Consumer Reports

Liberal chickens come home to roost -- THE water buffalo strike again.

Remember the "water buffalo" incident? In 1993, a University of Pennsylvania undergraduate yelled, "Shut up, you water buffalo" to noisy black students outside his campus residence. He was charged with racial harassment. The episode, two parts Kafka, one part Woody Allen, made nationwide news and even embarrassed liberals. At his Senate confirmation hearings to head the National Endowment for the Humanities, Sheldon Hackney, who as Penn president allowed campus radicals to turn the school into a Stalinist theme park, distanced himself from their shenanigans.

Once again, liberals condemn the very water buffalo they unleashed. Everywhere from Brown University to U Cal-Berkeley quasi-fascist protests have erupted over the advertisement against David Horowitz’s advertisement against reparations for slavery. Horowitz submitted the ad to 52 college newspapers. The majority rejected it. But a handful refused to buckle to campus storm troopers. The entire March 16 press run of the Brown Daily Herald was stolen after the paper published the advertisement and refused to give student critics free space for a rebuttal. Nevertheless, Brown's incoming and acting president both refrained from any forthright condemnation of the apparent criminal mischief by students.

The Brown incident and censorship antics elsewhere, did however, provoke genuine outrage from many denizens of the left-liberal universe. But like Frankstein's horrified creator, they have not quite mastered cause and effect.

In their March 22 letter to the Harvard Crimson, author David Halberstam and ultra-liberal New York Times columnist Anthony Lewis, both former Crimson managing editors, expresed surprise that "you rejected the [Horowitz] ad . . . You missed an opportunity--an easy opportunity--to show what freedom of speech is all about."

True, as far as it goes. Still, critics, on both the left and right, mostly consider the reaction to the advertisement a manifestation of intolerance and "sensitivity" run amok. But an even more insidious phenomenon is ultimately to blame: our nation's shameful double standard on race. Thanks to liberals like Lewis, the double standard has infested our culture, laws, and educational system. Lewis demands affirmative action and scores of other policies which assume that blacks should be treated differently than whites. Now, the very student newspapers he condemns have done just that. What else might he have expected?

When, at the behest of liberals, you subsume so many other time-honored and constitutionally-based values to race, why should free speech be different? Lewis's soulmate Jesse Jackson considers "merit" a white-male ploy to maintain power.

The "racial justice" crowd (race first, justice second) uses the same logic to dismiss free speech. Like the "meritocracy" it's just another white male charade. When campuses declare black skin privilege Uber Alles, no wonder free speech is consigned to the dustbin of bourgeois values.

It's been noted that many of the same newspapers, which published an infamous ad denying the Holocaust, refused to publish the Horowitz advertisement. Ironic, yes, but not parallel. The proper parallel would be an ad that denies slavery.

In our current culture, Horowitz committed a much more egregious offense. Simultaneously, he acknowledges our great nation's past crimes, but denies "civil rights advocates" the moral ammunition they've long wielded from American's enslavement of blacks. He even asks "What About The Debt Blacks Owe To America?"

No wonder the visceral reaction. Conversely, notice the racial double standard even among some liberal critics of the thought police. The March 20 Boston Globe editorial, Tolerance 101, seemed most concerned that the censorship would ultimately hurt blacks. Is that akin to worrying that book burners could suffer smoke inhalation? Yup. Listen to the Globe formulation: "Far more dangerous than offensive ideas is their censorship, BECAUSE [emph. added] censorship knows no ideology and will eventually muzzle the views of the minorities as well."

Notice the underlying logic: the problem with censorship is less that it thwarts our cherished right to free expression, but rather its potential harm to minorities.

Does this mean the Boston Globe finds intolerance a bit more tolerable if it advances the black agenda? Sure sounds that way. Wake up, Tony Lewis and other First Amendment paladins. The race card invariably renders free speech the joker.

JWR contributor Evan Gahr, a self-described neo-reactionary, is senior fellow at the Hudson Institute. To comment click here.


03/20/01: Teddy's FOBs --- Friends of Bush
03/16/01: Missile defense zealots
03/13/01: Stonewall Jackson strikes again
03/02/01: Only in New Yawk --- NOT!
02/28/01: Jesse the spendthrift? 'Moocher' is more like it!
02/21/01: Remember Saint Ralph?
02/17/01: Donna Brazile Speaks out on Clarence Thomas
02/15/01: Operation PUSH back
02/08/01: Of 'players,' boozers, and your tax dollars
02/02/01: Schumer's new insensitivity
01/31/01: The Real Pat Caddell
01/26/01: Louts Above the Law
01/18/01: Bush and other GOP converts to racial politics are profoundly misguided
12/20/00: Whose America? Here are some election results the "mainstream" press won't report
12/14/00: Gore's last smear campaign
12/05/00: Fido v. Fido --- the emerging 'pets' rights' movement
12/01/00: Missile defense fog
11/17/00: The Dersh opens his yap one time too many
11/13/00: Gore's biggest missing Florida bloc
11/07/00: Hillary's cruel blow to American pluralism
11/01/00: Given Hillary's history should anyone -- other than society's most radical -- be surprised?
10/26/00: Remembering Gus Hall, that 'all-American' kinda guy
10/19/00: Hey conservatives, Nader wants your vote!
08/24/00: Not So Super-Heroes
08/15/00: Meet Mr. Quotas
08/01/00:The Visigoths are coming! The Visigoths are coming! ... Or so the media thinks
07/12/00: Geraldo's Food for Thought
06/27/00: Time for To Execute a Murderer
06/20/00: Hillary and the Cop-bashers: Will the real Ms. Rodham please stand up?
06/08/00: For voting rights purposes, should criminal offenders be judged not by the content of their character but the color of their skin?
05/10/00: Feminist Majority Rule
05/02/00: The Tin Man's Doctor
03/07/00: Bob Jones hypocrisy: Liberals are lecturing Americans on "anti-Catholicism"?
02/03/00: The red and the Black: The Left-wing Extremist in Bill Bradley’s Camp
01/06/00: Looking backwards: An anchorman's version of the 20th Century
12/16/99: Yellow journalism for the Pink Lady?
12/07/99: How to make the American Psychological Association squirm

© 2001, Evan Gahr. This column first appeared on Front Page Magazine