Dec. 2, 2008 Melanie Phillips: The Mumbai atrocity is a wake-up call for a frighteningly unprepared world Stratfor Geopolitical Intelligence Report: Strategic Motivations for the Mumbai Attack Dec. 1, 2008 Max Freidlander, as told to Jacklyn C. Wadler: India Inkings Mark Steyn: Whodunit!? Nov. 28, 2008 Rabbi Ahron Rapps: An evil seed that didn't have to be Melanie Phillips: Carpe diem --- or can we all relax now? Nov. 26, 2008 Michael Feldberg: Meet the Orthodox Jew who laid groundwork for scientific development of ordnance that undergirds America's current world leadership Andrea Simantov: Shades of life Nov. 25, 2008 The Jewish Ethicist by Rabbi Dr. Asher Meir : Getting Emotional For Influence The Kosher Gourmet by Ethel G. Hofman : Thanksiving feast! Nov. 24, 2008 Rabbi S. Binyomin Ginsberg: 'I just Became a grandchild!' Barry Rubin: Don't flatter your enemies, protect your friends Nov. 21, 2008 Rabbi A. Henach Leibowitz: Money matters? Caroline B. Glick: Civilization walks the plank Nov. 20, 2008 Rabbi Avi Shafran: Bronfman's blindness The Kosher Gourmet By Linda Gassenheimer: Portobellos add a hearty flavor to pasta with pesto Nov, 19, 2008 The Jewish Ethicist by Rabbi Dr. Asher Meir : Spread the wealth? Jewish tradition and income equality Elliot B. Gertel: 'Mad Men': Tackling prejudices or reinforcing them? Nov, 18, 2008 Dr. Debby Schwarz Hirschhorn: The End of the Age of Reason Jonathan Tobin: Does Barack + Bibi = Disaster? Nov, 17, 2008 Rabbi Yonason Goldson: The End of the Age of Reason Diana West: Gulling Americans into making terror legit? Nov, 14, 2008 Rabbi A. Henach Leibowitz: The Power of Spiritual Inertia Caroline B. Glick: The perils ahead Nov, 13, 2008 Stratfor Intelligence Briefing: How Bush and Obama together could change the Middle East dynamic The Kosher Gourmet by JeanMarie Brownson: Sweet and savory, crispy and meltingly tender bestilla Nov, 12, 2008 The Jewish Ethicist by Rabbi Dr. Asher Meir : Tyrannical Co-Workers Michael Doyle: High Court to consider today donated monuments that may have religious messages in public parks Nov, 11, 2008 Frank J. Gaffney, Jr.: Will Obama stop government officials considering institutionalizing financial jihad? Jonathan Tobin: They Will Decide Their Own Fate Nov, 10, 2008 Rabbi Avi Shafran: $8 billion, modern-day Tower of Babel being built? Barry Rubin: A letter to the president-elect from a Middle East realist Nov, 7, 2008 Rabbi Francis Nataf: Of Children and Immortality Caroline B. Glick: Livni's Obama strategy Nov, 6, 2008 Rabbi Yonason Goldson: How I tricked a classroom of apathetic students into grasping the fallacy of moral relativism The Kosher Gourmet By Gina Kim: Tips for making the perfect soup --- includes recipes Nov, 5, 2008 The Jewish Ethicist By Rabbi Dr. Asher Meir: Destitute Debtors Bruce Weinstein: 'Religulos': Bad title,even worse movie Nov, 4, 2008 Frank J. Gaffney, Jr.: Treasury Dept. submits to Shariah law Frida Ghitis: A surprise for Obama in the Middle East Nov, 3, 2008 Jonathan Rosenblum: Who says Jews are Smart? Jonathan Tobin: Was He Wrong About Everything? March 22, 2007 J-Rhythms with Avraham Rosenblum: JWR's cutting-edge music program showcasing performers -- singers, song writers, musicians, and bands -- who learn and live the Torah lifestyle (OUR NEWEST IGODCAST !) Oct. 29, 2003 Mortimer B. Zuckerman: Graffiti On History's Walls (MUST-READ!)

Jewish World Review June 6, 2006 / 10 Sivan, 5766 Witness character By Rabbi Dr. Asher Meir Does an expert witness have to be impartial? http://www.JewishWorldReview.com | Q: Much of my income as a real estate appraiser comes from testifying as an expert witness. The litigants who hire me expect me to give low appraisals which will help them in court, and they'll stop hiring me if I don't meet their expectations. Can I tailor my testimony to the needs of my clients? A: In order to answer your question, we have to clarify a critical distinction. There is a big difference between a litigant or party to a trial and a witness in a trial. Everyone understands that the litigants are not impartial, and that their claims may be carefully crafted to help their case in court. But a witness is expected to provide only facts, and to be completely impartial. Ideally, even claims of the litigants should only reflect objective fact, or at least reasonable and defensible claims. The Torah warns the judge to "Distance yourself from falsehood" (Exodus 23:7); the Talmud explains that in order to maintain this "distance" the parties to a lawsuit must help the judge by making only factual claims, even if a fraudulent claim is necessary to achieve a just outcome. Even so, absolute objectivity is not expected of a litigant, and this is certainly true in the adversary system we find in the secular court system. There is some legitimacy for each side to make claims which are most likely to result in a favorable trial outcome. We applied this idea in an earlier column, where we explained that an accountant is permitted to make a novel interpretation of a tax law in order to help his client, as long as he believes the interpretation can be defended. The accountant doesn't have to pretend that he is a judge making an objective determination if his understanding is correct. He is making a claim, and if the tax authorities disagree then they are welcome to make their own counterclaim and let the judge decide. By the same token, if your client wants to claim that his property has a low value, you can help prepare documents which tend to support that, as long as they don't violate basic standards of your profession. But a much different standard applies to a witness. A witness is never allowed to distort the truth. Even if a witness is called by one side, he is testifying on behalf of the court, not on behalf of a litigant. Jewish law is particularly strict on this point. The Torah forbids for a person even to pretend he is willing to serve as a witness in order to intimidate the other litigant into settling! This is true even if the decoy witness is convinced that this will lead to justice being done. The basis for this rule is again the verse, "Distance yourself from untruth." (Exodus 23:7.) It's not enough not to distort justice; we have to distance ourselves from injustice by avoiding distorting the judicial process. That does not mean that the expert witness needs to be totally impartial. It is natural that he has some inclination to the position of the side which engaged him. This "inclination" has an interesting parallel in Jewish law. One very popular kind of Beis Din (rabbinical court) proceeding is "zabla", an acronym for "ze borer lo echad", meaning that each litigant chooses one judge and the two judges together choose a third. The three-judge panel then tries the case. Some commentators explain that each chosen judge will be likely to emphasize the strong points of the case of the litigant who chose him — to bring them to the attention of the other judges. Once all of the facts are brought to light, all judges will of course judge impartially. By the same token, it is understandable if an expert witness is particularly careful to emphasize those points which are favorable to the side which hired him, and is more taciturn regarding those which are favorable to the other side. But this is not the same as making statements which go against your professional judgment and training. The real problem is with the system. An expert witness is an unfortunate hybrid — engaged and paid by one side yet expected to provide impartial testimony! The ideal situation in cases where expertise is required would be for both sides to agree on an expert. It would be wonderful if judges would instruct litigants to try and agree on an expert in such cases — just as judges sometimes instruct the sides to try to reach a settlement or to engage in mediation. Then there would be a strong incentive for the appraiser to be right on target, since the most accurate appraisers would get the most business. If you have a strong reputation as a skilled and accurate assessor, perhaps you could get business from disputants who will use you as an arbitrator. They will prefer to take their case to you rather than to court, knowing that they will get a fair judgment at a bargain rate since they don't have to pay the lawyers. SOURCES: Babylonian Talmud, Shavuos 31a, Sanhedrin 23a; Maimonides Mishneh Torah Laws of Pleading 16:9; Shulchan Aruch, Choshen Mishpat 13:1, and Shach commentary on 75:1 Every weekday JewishWorldReview.com publishes inspiring articles. Sign up for our daily update. It's free. Just click here. THE JEWISH ETHICIST, NOW IN BOOK FORM You've enjoyed his columns on JWR for years. Now the Jewish Ethicist has culled his most intriguing — and controversial — offerings in book form. HARDCOVER PAPERBACK Sales help fund JWR. JWR contributor Rabbi Dr. Asher Meir, formerly of the Council of Economic Advisers in the Reagan administration, is Research Director of the Business Ethics Center of Jerusalem, Jerusalem College of Technology. To comment or pose a question, please click here. Previously: Should I give recognition to a modest man who did a great deed? In representing my firm, can I tell a white lie? Defrauding insurance to save a life Can top level management unilaterally give away money to corporate dollars to charity? Loans to Family Members How much worker supervision is too much? Should I turn in a colleague for inappropriate acts? Priority in charitable giving Trolls and ogres How many hours of work is too many? Can I promote my product by having it unobtrusively written into a story? He's not heavy he's my brother All's fair in war?, II All's fair in war? Girth vs. worth Is it proper to tax bequests? Ethics of Being Overweight Penalized for working swiftly When is it a bluff? 'Rate and switch' My paycheck is late! Should schools cater to an elite? All's fair in love? Comfort and Competition Do I need the caller's permission to put a call on the speakerphone? Overtime for lost time Is it unethical to play suppliers against each other to get the lowest bid possible? Do family members have precedence in charity allotments? What the world of business can teach us about our annual process of repentance and renewal Are religious leaders subject to criticism? Vindictive Vendor: How can I punish an abusive competitor? Blogging Ethics: Is the blogger responsible for defamatory posts? © 2005, The Jewish Ethicist is produced by the JCT Center for Business Ethics