Jewish World Review Nov. 15, 1999 /6 Kislev, 5760
Strength in diversity? Not
OF THE MANY MYTHS of liberalism, perhaps the most improbable is the notion
that diversity makes us stronger.
Last week, New York City's planning department released a report on
patterns of immigration to the Big Apple. From 1990 to 1996, roughly 113,000
immigrants settled there each year, the overwhelming majority from the Third
The report positively glowed about the supposed benefits of this influx.
Many city neighborhoods have become delightfully polyglot. Why, in a single
block, the products of dozens of different countries are sold.
True, there has been somewhat of a strain on the city's schools, which have
had to accommodate students from 196 different countries. Those in bilingual
education cost twice the average to educate.
And, along with polyglot products, New Yorkers have imported crime and
poverty. The city's foreign-born represent 28 percent of its population, but
comprise half of those on welfare.
As immigrants arrived, the native-born fled. New York's non-Hispanic white
population has plummeted from 63 percent in 1970 to 35 percent today. Due to
immigration, nationally, whites will constitute a minority by 2050.
In the city, the fastest-growing immigrant groups are from Ghana, Nigeria,
Bangladesh and Egypt. These countries are all impoverished (Bangladesh's per
capita Gross Domestic Product is $1260), backward (Egypt has a 49 percent
illiteracy rate) and far removed from our culture.
While Mayor Rudy Guiliani's administration celebrates diversity, ordinary
Americans aren't putting on party hats. The Nov. 8 Miami Herald reports on a
poll showing: "Floridians are not in a welcoming mood when it comes to new
immigrants. They favor strongly reducing legal immigration to the United
Hispanics are the only group that doesn't, and then by only 51 percent (40
percent favor cutbacks). The Herald quotes a Cuban immigrant who warns that
America is "like a ship that can take on only so many passengers before
Many of us understand what the elite does not: That due to unrestrained
immigration and multiculturalism, America is losing its identity.
Although New York's report alludes to Ellis Island, today's immigrants are
another story. The Irish, Italian and Jewish immigrants of yesterday all
came from countries connected to Western culture.
On arrival, they were told in no uncertain terms what was expected of
them -- to assimilate by adopting our language, learning our history and
identifying with American values.
Today, an elite which is guilty about America's past and unsure of the
value of our culture tells them: Don't assimilate. Why learn English? Why
should you want to identify with a nation founded by white males with guns?
Don't even become a hyphenated American; remain a whatever who happens to reside here.
Dan Stein, executive director of the Federation for American Immigration
Reform, observes that as far as liberals are concerned there's "virtually
nothing" for today's immigrants to attach themselves to "other than rampant
consumerism" and a "vague concept of diversity."
Has a country ever grown stronger through disunity? Our differences may
make us interesting; they do not unite us. What happens when a growing
portion of the population feels no allegiance to ouv onational ideals,
disdains our heroes and clings to its separateness?
In the past, we could absorb and ultimately Americanize millions of
immigrants because of our shared identity. Today, that common ground is fast
Last week, the Pope was in India pleading with its inhabitants not to
murder Christians. In the past two years, there have been more than 150
reported incidents of murder, rape, beatings and church desecration.
India is deliriously diverse. There are Hindus, Moslems, Sikhs and
Christians, castes and sub-groups. For hundreds of years they've all been at
each others throats. For most of its existence, India was held together only
by the bloody swords of rajahs or British lances. Is this the America under
construction for our children and grandchildren?
You can bet the authors of the New York report don't live in diverse
neighborhoods, send their children to diverse schools or experience the joys
of immigrant culture by strolling the streets of Washington Heights, with
its Jamaican gangs, 'round midnight.
The elite celebrates diversity; others have to live with
JWR contributing columnist Don Feder's latest book is Who's Afraid of the Religious Right. Comment on his column by clicking here.
Don Feder Archives
©1999, Creators Syndicate