Machlokes / Controversy

Jewish World Review March 8, 1999 / 20 Adar, 5759


A. Engler Anderson

‘Spies and bags of money’


Critic: U.S. must clean up foreign policy act


IF GEN. AUGUSTO PINOCHET is brought to justice for human rights abuses in Chile, one of the people responsible uncovering evidence of United States’ involvement will have been Washington lawyer Jack Blum.

"I think Pinochet deserves everything he gets," says Blum. "You will note the silence of the United States in the whole Pinochet affair. We are silent because we are complicit."

Blum should know. He led the Senate probe into ITT’s role, with the Central Intelligence Agency, in aiding the 1973 coup that overthrew the popularly elected government of Salvador Allende, kicking off 17 years of bloody military rule.

Blum says that the ethics must inform how we conduct foreign relations. "This is a core issue of Judaism," says Blum, 58, who once trudged around the Lower East Side with a tome of Talmud as a bachur at the famed Rabbi Jacob Joseph Yeshiva, and is president emeritus of Reform Temple Shalom in Arnold, Md.

"We have some very strong imperatives about caring for the downtrodden, for the poor, worrying about the imprisoned and caring about justice. But these things tend to get wiped out when you begin supporting a thug who is your political pal.

"From a Jewish view, this is terribly offensive — if you take anything in Torah seriously."

Blum also led congressional probes into the activities of one-time U.S. ally Gen. Manuel Noreiga, the Iran-Contra Affair, and overseas bribes by defense contractor Lockheed Aircraft. Now that the Cold War is over, he says the United States must clean up its foreign policy act. "We worked with all kinds of people who were against labor and the left" in the fight against communism.

"But the coalition that emerged was very pro-U.S. but it also turned out to be a corrupt system.

"We’ve been involved in a Cold War which has had policymakers cutting corners, and most of the policymaking has been done covertly," Blum says. "Is the solution to send in spies and bags of money, or is the solution to really work on democratic governments? Is that best done by sending in diplomats, or military people?"

He says policymakers need to take a cold, hard look at foreign aid. "A huge amount of money that the World Bank has dispersed has been flat out stolen," he says. "The reason is that the people who have been stealing have been our pals and that has to be stopped."

Blum is no stranger to corporate crime and official corruption. He came to Washington as antitrust counsel under mentor, Sen. Phil Hart. Later, on the staff of the Senate Foreign Relations Committee, he looked into overseas payments by Lockheed Aircraft, Third World loans by American banks, the oil industry, and ITT involvement in Chile.

Bad policy sometimes starts at home. "How much is inspired by very crass domestic politics?" he asks. "We can’t change Cuban policy because everybody is afraid the Miami Cubans would go crazy."

On Israel, he says U.S. policy should be informed "by altruism" and "by what is right." He says that policymakers need to jettison the idea that the Jewish community is a monolithic vote that will support everything the Israeli government proposes. "How much support the Netanyahu government has in the Reform Jewish community is an open question," he says.


A. Engler Anderson, a staff reporter for Boston's Jewish Advocate, is moderator of J-PEN: Forum for Jewish Journalism & Journalists. His personal home page can be reached by clicking here.

Up

02/16/99: Congregant fires salvo in conversion war

©1999, Boston Jewish Advocate