|
|
|
Jewish World Review March 1, 2005 / 20 Adar I, 5765 Free Speech failing on campus By Jack Kelly
http://www.JewishWorldReview.com |
The saga of Ward Churchill illustrates why there is no greater consumer
fraud in America today than "higher" education.
Churchill was until recently the chairman of the department of ethnic
studies at the University of Colorado. He resigned the post after it came to
light that he had likened those killed in the World Trade Center on 9/11 to
Nazi war criminals.
Churchill's sentiments are not rare on college faculties these days, but
most such anti-American drivel passes below the public's radar. Churchill
had the misfortune of having his remarks come to the attention of Fox News'
Bill O'Reilly, who took umbrage, as did his audience.
The uproar has brought to light other facts about Churchill that are
embarrassing to the University of Colorado.
Churchill's academic credentials are poor. He has BA and MA degrees from
Sangamon State University, a diploma mill in Springfield, Ill., but not the
PhD normally considered de rigueur for a full professor.
CU bypassed normal procedures to grant Churchill tenure. It wasn't because
of his scholarship. Thomas Brown, a professor of sociology at Lamar
University, said Churchill made up "facts" in a paper he wrote asserting the
Army intentionally created a smallpox epidemic among the Mandan tribe in
1837, and then attributed these "facts" to sources which said nothing of the
kind. University of New Mexico law professor John Lavelle said Churchill
made up stuff in an article on federal law concerning Indian lands.
Lavelle also accused Churchill of plagiarism, and the CBS affiliate in
Denver reported that Churchill has sold mirror images of Indian art work
created by others as his own.
Churchill was hired and promoted because he claimed to be a Cherokee Indian.
The Cherokees say he isn't, and researchers for the Rocky Mountain News have
been unable to find a drop of Indian blood among his ancestors.
Churchill is still a professor at CU, but Colorado Gov. Bill Owens wants him
fired, and the regents are considering it.
Churchill says his First Amendment right to free speech is being violated.
But this claim is as phony as Churchill's Indian heritage and his
scholarship. The First Amendment says the government can't put you in jail
for what you say. But nothing in the constitution guarantees you the right
to a $96,000 job at taxpayer expense. If I were to write in this column
that the editor of the newspaper where I work is an idiot, the government
wouldn't put me in jail. But I'd soon be unemployed.
Some 200 professors at CU have bought a newspaper ad demanding that the
inquiry into Churchill be dropped. "It's going to be extremely difficult,
if academic freedom is on the block, for us to hire and keep good faculty
members," said Margaret LeCompte, an education professor.
But Churchill's defenders are highly selective in defending free speech, as
the controversy over Lawrence Summers at Harvard illustrates.
At a conference in January, Summers noted that despite vigorous efforts to
recruit women for vacancies, the faculty in the hard sciences and higher
mathematics remained overwhelmingly male. Summers speculated that this
might in part be due to a difference in cognitive skills between men and
women. Men, he said, are more likely to be either math geniuses or math
dunces, while mathematical reasoning skills are more evenly distributed
among women.
MIT Biology professor Nancy Hopkins said she was made ill by the remarks,
providing a real life example of the misogynist stereotype of the little
woman with the vapors. Andrea Peyser, an idiot who writes for the New York
Post, said Summers had said men were more intelligent than women. That was
not at all what he said, but Peyser's inability to follow Summers' argument
lends support to the thesis as she stated it.
As it happens, researchers at the University of New Mexico and the
University of California-Irvine have demonstrated through a study of brain
scans that men and women do process information differently.
Churchill is lionized for saying vile and untrue things about his country
and countrymen. Summers is hounded for saying something non-pejorative that
is demonstrably true. This is the status of free speech on campuses today.
Every weekday JewishWorldReview.com publishes what many in Washington and the media consider "must-reading". Sign up for the daily JWR update. It's free. Just click here.
© 2005, Jack Kelly | ||||||||||
